I think the difference is that most Americans simply aren't exposed to various ways of writing dates, times, currencies, numbers, etc. on a regular basis.
Even within Germany, there's no consensus about where to put the Euro sign (before or after). Americans don't write times like 20:00 and say "eight" aloud. After several years in Europe, I'm fairly adept at accepting all inputs.
Your comment inspired this thought: Imagine a Firefox extension or Greasemonkey script that localizes web pages: converts dates, times, currencies, separators to the user's preference. :)
Google Chrome will translate web page languages, which is a much more difficult problem.
Why that is, I can only take a stab at: I guess we see a lot more from you guys on the other side of the pond than you see from us. :)
[1] Comma overload -- my English teacher would kill me.