In their defense, artificial scarcity can drive buzz for the product a lot, if done well. Also, a service that's not yet done can't afford to launch to the public, especially when there's money involved.
Rather than think about launching in beta vs launching publicly, think about launching in beta vs launching much later. Which is the better choice?
Re:Flattr - I want to give you my money
by citricsquid on Tuesday April 26, 2011 @07:51PM
(#2487767)
In the case of Flattr? The latter would have been much more beneficial for them. I wanted to sign up to give them my money, to improve the value of their service (the value for content providers is the amount of users) and I had to "apply" and wait for it. Everything about that is wrong for Flattr.
So it would be better for flattr if you weren't even aware of their existence, rather than know about them and be unable to sign up? I don't believe that...
I think they fit more into the Google Wave category than say the gmail. With gmail everyone could instantly gain value from having an account, with wave, people fired it up, had a quick look around and noticing none of their friends were there to talk to forgot about it.
Re:Flattr - I want to give you my money
by watchandwait on Tuesday April 26, 2011 @10:40PM
(#2488161)
People forget that PayPal got started by literally giving money away -- $10 -- to get people to sign up.
Re:Flattr - I want to give you my money
by fleaflicker on Tuesday April 26, 2011 @10:15PM
(#2488113)
Could reddit pull this off? Their "reddit this" buttons are already everywhere.
Hmm, that sounds like it might have some potential. I'm envisioning a setup where the first upvote is free, but you can get a second one by spending a quarter (or whatever amount of money) that gets shared with the site owner.
Or Facebook. Their "Like" buttons are everything and I'm sure Facebook would love to collect money from users, not just advertisers.
They shot themselves in the foot when they launched the service: a "private beta". It was the most ridiculous idea ever, here is a service that NEEDS every user they can get vaguely interested to sign up and use it, and then when they have users interested (the initial launch "buzz") they say "nope sorry, it's a private beta, we'll send you an invite some time".
I used Flattr for a while and so little sites used it I just ended my subscription. I was lucky to get an invite too... they should have been trying to take everyone who WANTED to use the service, instead they pushed them away.