People are asked to put value on intangibles all the time. You might want to write them all down to zero, but the rest of us value Wordsworth more than the dead trees his words are printed on.
Ex. If I make $2000 a week as a contractor on a steady contract, I know that the opportunity cost of taking a week of unpaid vacation time is $2000. That's a reasonable, measurable assumption.
However, I could also say that the opportunity cost of that week of vacation will be $12000, because there might be a one-week rush project that will come in that I can bill for $10000 in addition to my normal steady contract. Assuming there's not a pattern of that happening in the past, it's not a reasonable assumption and thus measurable in that way.
I'd say this second scenario is akin to the record companies assuming that every instance of piracy is also an instance of lost sales.
Goodwill can be measured in the sense that goodwill = purchase price - book value. No assumptions are involved in its calculations--goodwill is calculated based on two fixed values.
Opportunity costs are not as concrete. In your example above you state your opportunity cost is $2000...but what if that rush project comes through? What if your steady contract scales back for that week? There are assumptions involved; ideally your opportunity cost would be the expected value of all probable incomes during that week. Identifying those probabilities a priori is impossible.
My point is: opportunity costs are based on assumptions. They cannot be measured--only estimated.
My point was that Microsoft probably had some revenue trajectory with slope X before the write-down, and experienced a new revenue trajectory with slope Y < X after the write-down. I'm curious about the area between the two lines.
First, most of the time when we're talking about business and we talk about costs we're clearly talking about accounting costs. This applies to startups, too. When you're talking about accounting costs, you don't get to include economic costs (e.g., opportunity cost.)
Second, isn't trying to include these extra "costs" due to lost sales the same thing that the music industry is doing? That is, claiming that they lost trillions of dollars due to file sharing from, you got it, "lost sales." [1]
I don't think there's any real way to measure these costs, so let's stop trying.
[1] http://www.p2pon.com/2011/03/25/greed-hits-climax-music-indu...