Re:1 + 1 (pat. pending) — Mathematics, Software and Free Speech
by jbri on Tuesday April 26, 2011 @08:46PM
(#2487916)
The predominant claim is that the machine has already been invented, and a new input to the existing machine should not be patentable.
Re:1 + 1 (pat. pending) — Mathematics, Software and Free Speech
by jamii on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @03:59AM
(#2488778)
A much stronger argument against patents, which the OP only touched upon, is the existence of FOSS. Patents exist to encourage the disclosure of ideas but FOSS already provides an excellent mechanism for this. Not only that, but the existence of software patents is damaging to the FOSS community which generally cannot afford to navigate the idea minefield. Software patents don't even require disclosing enough information to actually implement the idea so in many cases there is zero benefit to society.
Judges also need to be made aware just how much of the modern information age is built upon FOSS.
Re:1 + 1 (pat. pending) — Mathematics, Software and Free Speech
by baddox on Tuesday April 26, 2011 @06:43PM
(#2487536)
Some people (okay, maybe just me) aren't huge fans of intellectual property protection because, like you say, all invention/creation is making something new from existing parts. The property analogy doesn't hold up in my opinion, especially in the Information Age.
The fact that running a piece of software is predictable (the same program runs the same way with the same inputs), is not a strong argument. A machine (with physical gears) will perform the same function when run in the exact same conditions. Just because one is an analog machine and one is a digital machine doesn't change the concept of invention: making something new from existing parts.