Re:A “perfect” voting system
by yesbabyyes on Tuesday April 26, 2011 @04:16PM
(#2486976)
That's true - if everyone votes on their own, it's direct democracy.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I was thinking about an essentially identical system to yours some years ago and I came up with an amendment to prevent direct democracy (if desired): nobody can vote for themselves unless they have at least X votes; if not then they must delegate.
Similarly you could try to assemble everyone who has at least X votes into a parliament (if you pick X appropriately), though I'm worried that the cutoff for getting into parliament might cause a chain of tactical redelegations which never stabilizes.
Re:A “perfect” voting system
by yesbabyyes on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @04:38AM
(#2488834)
Thanks for these insights, both are interesting. I've thought about the same thing with the parliament, but I fear there are problems with that. If it turns out that there is a fairly stable selection at the top it might work and should make the voting more efficient.