News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Hypertext annotated version of “A Fire Upon the Deep”... by rsync on Friday October 23, 2020 @09:39AM (#24869320)
"I believe it remains one of the seminal works in SF, and holds up pretty well today."

I enjoyed tremendously _A Deepness in the Sky_ and continue to find the ideas interesting and thought-provoking - especially the localizer networks, etc.

Based on that I read _Fire Upon the Deep_ and found it very enjoyable and interesting throughout, but then deeply disappointing at the end. I was expecting explanations and resolutions of the deep background events and actors that were shaping the story and none were given.

Re:The Hypertext annotated version of “A Fire Upon the Deep”... by jerf on Friday October 23, 2020 @09:42AM (#24869346)
"then deeply disappointing at the end. I was expecting explanations and resolutions of the deep background events and actors that were shaping the story and none were given."

If you read carefully, and make a couple of reasonable deductions, I think you can come to mostly satisfactory conclusions. There's room for a couple of different interpretations of what's in the center of the galaxy, but not all that many, really.

Re:The Hypertext annotated version of “A Fire Upon the Deep”... by vintagedave on Friday October 23, 2020 @10:12AM (#24869691)
Could you explain your own deductions, please? What are the possible interpretations?

I have read both novels, but on that reading do not feel I could be sure of understanding what's at the galactic center at all. In fact, I recall feeling puzzled and wishing it was explained, much like the parent poster. I'd love to hear some deductions and to find out what hints in the book I missed.

Edit: I see you also wrote this comment - very informative, thanks! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24869467