News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Spotify revises TOS to allow transfers of user-created pl... by aviraldg on Friday October 23, 2020 @07:40AM (#24868395)
I don't understand GDPR too well -- does this mean every company must build APIs that would be sufficient to allow competitors to import user data from them?
Re:Spotify revises TOS to allow transfers of user-created pl... by TonyTrapp on Friday October 23, 2020 @08:34AM (#24868763)
I guess the relevant section also quoted in the original post by Confiks ("the data subject shall have the right to have the personal data transmitted directly from one controller to another, where technically feasible") may be up for interpretation, and as a result not everyone might have provide such an API. But this specific case, we can be sure that it most definitely was technically feasible, as the feature used to work before their ToS change and it merely stopped working because they wanted to block SongShift.
Re:Spotify revises TOS to allow transfers of user-created pl... by tpxl on Friday October 23, 2020 @08:40AM (#24868815)
You don't have to provide an API to transfer between accounts on the same platform, but you do need to provide a way to get all your data off the service, which another service can use to import.
Re:Spotify revises TOS to allow transfers of user-created pl... by disiplus on Friday October 23, 2020 @12:25PM (#24871150)
read the emails this person sent to spotify.
Re:Spotify revises TOS to allow transfers of user-created pl... by tpxl on Monday October 26, 2020 @06:28PM (#24902267)
The API was already implemented and shut off. He did not as them to implement the API, he asked them to turn it back on and there is a large difference.
Re:Spotify revises TOS to allow transfers of user-created pl... by okamiueru on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @01:14PM (#24909484)
Am I alone in thinking he isn't entirely correct? To my understanding with GDPR (I'm no expert, just on the developer end trying to adhere to it), he has all the right to get a copy of the data, as well as have that data be transferred to another controller.

He does, however have no say in the exact data transfer protocol used for the transfer. If Spotify wants to disable an api and shut down production resources, I don't see how a GDPR request can compel them otherwise. As long as they prepare all the data, and allow for the transfer, then they are complying with GDPR. Even if the API at some point existed, it doesn't mean they are required to maintain it.

The other side of this is that Spotify's answers were perhaps too earnest in detailing why. When arguing it is against their ToS, it doesn't really fly with GDPR anymore, because that implies they have everything in place, but they don't want to. They could have just said "we'll compile all the data and facilitate a transfer on your behalf", and the user really wouldn't have the slightest case.

So to sum up, my take is that both are wrong. Spotify in arguing its against their ToS (it doesn't fly). And the emailer arguing that they are entitled to Spotify enabling their api (they aren't).

Re:Spotify revises TOS to allow transfers of user-created pl... by tpxl on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @05:56PM (#24912411)
Afaik GDPR says where it's technically feasible. The interpretation of technically feasible may vary, but given that the API was live for some time, it could be said it is feasible.

That being said I am no lawyer and I don't know what I'm talking about.

Re:Spotify revises TOS to allow transfers of user-created pl... by okamiueru on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:17AM (#24928591)
That is more or less why I wrote the things I wrote. By arguing it was against their ToS, they implied it was technically feasible. It however doesn't mean it isn't also technically infeasible, so I still believe Spotify could take a big fat dump of the data in any format they chose, zip it up and send it to the other controller, and it would be within the GDPR requirements.

If people think that GDPR grants consumers the right on which services exist and how data should represented etc, then I think they are misinformed.

Spotify could have answered with "That API is no longer available, but we will facilitate the transfer of an archived version of the data", and... I mean, what clause of GDPR does he have to complain or demand they do anything different?

Re:Spotify revises TOS to allow transfers of user-created pl... by parliament32 on Friday October 23, 2020 @12:27PM (#24871165)
No: the root of the matter is that it has to be "technically feasible", which with proprietary software you can't ever prove. This was a special case because they already showed it was possible (it was working), then they took it away.
Re:Spotify revises TOS to allow transfers of user-created pl... by emn13 on Friday October 23, 2020 @03:01PM (#24872679)
Even here, if they reaaaaalllly cared (and had good reasons to, other than "we want to lock in customers"), they probably could take the feature away - they'd just need to play the CYA game much better, and be willing to risk a hefty fine based on whether a court believes your reasons for technical infeasibility. After all, not everything that was technically feasible stays so in a changing environment.

Another think they can do is just try occasionally, and see if people give up.

Re:Spotify revises TOS to allow transfers of user-created pl... by mjburgess on Friday October 23, 2020 @07:51AM (#24868465)
It does seem onerous. I wonder if, "so, we will email SongShift directly" etc., would do.

I guess the law doesn't say "for free" ? So perhaps they could charge a fee for each API use...

It otherwise seems unreasonable to require data-holders (/"controllers") to pay the costs of this "direct transfer", esp. re building and maintaining an API.

They have in their possession an object which the user owns -- their data -- would we, in analogous cases, require stores to do anything other than "hand it back" ?

This seems quite an odd law.

EDIT: given downvotes, let me clarify: I like the law. It is useful. I just want to understand the moral/legal/economic logic.

This law imposes costs somewhere, and prevents some services being offered.

Re:Spotify revises TOS to allow transfers of user-created pl... by aenario on Friday October 23, 2020 @09:44AM (#24869381)
An alternative is to think of data as dangerous chemicals.

You can acquire it and store it, but you have to follow some procedures : - do not expose your employees to it - do not leak it in the environment

It then falls to the company to make the cost/benefit analysis : is this chemical important enough to our process to justify these hasles.

The data export also does not need to be a perfect API, dump a huge json and let third party handle changes.

Re:Spotify revises TOS to allow transfers of user-created pl... by Nullabillity on Friday October 23, 2020 @08:07AM (#24868561)
> It otherwise seems unreasonable to require data-holders (/"controllers") to pay the costs of this "direct transfer", esp. re building and maintaining an API.

Consider it a cost of collecting the data in the first place.

Re:Spotify revises TOS to allow transfers of user-created pl... by mjburgess on Friday October 23, 2020 @08:11AM (#24868589)
You're assuming that they are deriving additional value from it. That isn't universal, but the law is.

Eg., consider me uploading some image files for processing and then downloading them. The website keeps those images only insofar as I wish, and never analyses them or derives value from them beyond what I permit -- and suppose the default is to permit nothing.

Then it seems odd. Since this is more like taking my shoes to be repaired. It would be onerous to require repair shops to send them elsehwere.

Re:Spotify revises TOS to allow transfers of user-created pl... by asdfasgasdgasdg on Friday October 23, 2020 @08:23AM (#24868693)
I think the theory is if the data controller does not derive value from storing the data they should not do so. In spotify's case they plainly do. Without user created playlists they would be up a creek.
Re:Spotify revises TOS to allow transfers of user-created pl... by corobo on Friday October 23, 2020 @01:36PM (#24871871)
If they get no value from it they're free to delete it