Plus, you’ll have the added benefit of a chip on your shoulder wanting to prove you are as good as those colleagues that paid 200k.
Chips on shoulders put chips in pockets.
These type of studies are not meant for advancement, they are meant for reflection and sense making.
I also think people tend to underestimate the positive externalities of the humanities departments. (Nobody reads academic history mostly, but the existence of historians makes bullshit claims more difficult.)
I think your proposed study groups would work at first, but eventually wouldn't be able to sustain themselves as the scholarly communities providing the background vocabulary and paradigms you need to even have a conversation collapsed.
I swear somewhere here or elsewhere I read a story that one of the major quantum computing contributions that accelerated the field was essentially the result of a faculty member spending several years doing nothing but teaching and thinking about the problem, with no grants or anything but salary. Maybe it's a myth or I'm misremembering it though; I've tried searching for it (to confirm or disconfirm my memory) with no luck because of the volumes of irrelevant results.
Also, history is an interesting example, as it seems one of the first sets of experts everyone seemed to turn to with all the events of the last few years are historians. "What happened with previous pandemics?" "How did past pandemics effect economics of the time?" "What did people do then?" "Is this the first time this situation occurred?" So forth and so on. The more "unprecedented" the problem the further back in history people will look for precedents and guidance.
It also seems implausible to me that the same sorts of history research could happen by hobbyists as happens at universities, just due to time and funding constraints.
There's a lot of problems in academics at the moment, at least in the US, but I think 2/3 of it is actually coming from outside those in the field (pick your field). Administration problems, federal incentives, state incentives, private incentives (yes, corporate management requiring useless degrees or offloading employee training elsewhere to decrease investment costs and its consequences) etc etc etc
I still don’t see why there should be no creativity. Left to their own devices the university system has produced worse product at higher prices for decades. The time has come for innovation.
i agree there are huge problems with higher education, but I think if all humanities departments were disbanded as you suggest, you would miss them after they were gone.
Look at how terrible and shallow a lot of journalism and popular nonfiction is. Imagine if that was the highest level of thought available on most topics. Nothing but Medium posts forever.
We shall see if I’m right, as there aren’t any alternatives.
Universities shouldn't be judged as businesses, it's the exact opposite of their reason for existing. You need freedom and leisure not tied to economic pressure to do research and create a reflective infrastructure for humanity.
It was always subsidized by the ruling class, be it a king, or the society via taxes in democratic times.
The thought that everything is a business and should be analyzed as such is just shortsighted and lazy thinking.
Competition is not always good.
An online study group can replace Shackleton Bailey? That's just nuts. Literature requires deep study (and perhaps we shouldn't foist it on every last kid seeking a paid career in nursing, but that's a different topic).
If you kill the humanities, your entire colture will be defined by what ever sells, and religion.
Good luck with that.
Now universities have to operate like a business. Revenue is down and isn’t going to come back for a long time. Consolidation for the lucky and bankruptcy for the unlucky. Honestly it’s a good thing to happen, the sector produces way too much nonsense (we don’t need more papers on 19th century fiction authors that no one reads but other academics) and costs far too much. Society simply doesn’t need this waste anymore with the internet able to provide esoteric knowledge to the masses for free.
I’m fine with my tax dollars funding fundamental scientific research, but an online study group can enable people to study the classics and debate what it means to be a good person. A lot of these majors should not be funded by the state anymore.