News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Please bring back comment scores by Terretta on Tuesday April 26, 2011 @11:54AM (#2485772)
> Since I can't see your score, and you can't see mine, I honestly have no idea at this point whether more people agree with you than with me... When this thread is referenced to a week from now there is no way to see what sort of agreement occurred with either one of us.

It's almost as though the future reader would need to form an opinion... for themselves.

Re:Tell HN: Please bring back comment scores by redler on Tuesday April 26, 2011 @12:25PM (#2485947)
The readers here tend toward the more sophisticated end of the spectrum, and of course the presence of scores doesn't preclude future readings in depth. We all understand that scores are blunt indicators, but why not have access to that information? Knowing how the community "graded" a particular comment is an interesting piece of meta-information, even if you believe the cognitive anchoring effect diminishes its value as an indicator of the relative quality of the comment. But given the quality of the audience, high scores are likely to be positively correlated with quality comments, don't you think?
Re:Tell HN: Please bring back comment scores by Terretta on Tuesday April 26, 2011 @01:13PM (#2486186)
> high scores are likely to be positively correlated with quality comments, don't you think?

"likely ... positive", granted, but strong correlation, no.

Keep in mind the change was an experiment to mitigate effects of HN growth and the corresponding trend towards average of audience. The "tend" you mention had been unquestionably moving back to the middle.

That said, I don't have a problem with points switching on after the comments page goes to archive mode. I can ignore them then, while those who want to see them then can neither vote based on bias nor vote to correct perceived bias.

Discussion and reading should be thoughtful instead based on clicks

One's own comments can be self-appraised by seeing one's own score in real time, influencing one's own future thoughtfulness.

Re:Tell HN: Please bring back comment scores by redler on Tuesday April 26, 2011 @04:56PM (#2487185)
There are strong opinions and good arguments on both sides. Perhaps we should leave scores hidden, but provide a user preference to turn them on -- after reaching a certain karma level. If one argues that the rapid growth of the site has led to an exaggerated score influence, maybe a "norming" period makes sense. Downvoting privileges have to be "earned," so why not score visibility?
Re:Tell HN: Please bring back comment scores by estel on Tuesday April 26, 2011 @12:10PM (#2485858)
But that doesn't negate the value in seeing which side of the debate was most widely agreed upon at the time.

Edit: of course, this argument would be satisfied by no more than making comment scores visible on discussions older than n days.