Re:Tesla Earning Result 3Q 2020 [pdf]
by Diederich on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:47PM
(#24853094)
> And electric cars are actually responsible for even more emissions - not from burning fuel, obviously, but just manufacturing it releases more carbon dioxide than an average gas-powered car will in its 25 years lifecycle.
I don't believe this is true. This video crunches the numbers pretty thoroughly: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6RhtiPefVzM
"The main takeaway from this video: Electric cars certainly aren't any worse for the environment than gasoline cars regardless of where your energy comes from, and in the vast majority of cases, they are vastly superior to gasoline cars."
Re:Tesla Earning Result 3Q 2020 [pdf]
by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:52PM
(#24853139)
But its not about the energy - its about the cost of materials, which is a rough estimate of its impact on the environment. And that big old exotic-metal battery has got to have an impact?
Which "exotic-metals" go into a battery? Lithium isn't. Cobolt isn't really either, and it is equally used for gasoline cars. Nor are really manganese or nickel. And all of them can be recycled.
And how much material is needed for the oil drilling and transportation, which will no longer be needed going forward?
Re:Tesla Earning Result 3Q 2020 [pdf]
by Diederich on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:20AM
(#24858296)
There's a lot of analysis online about these topics, and more importantly, the total cost/impact/negative externalities associated with battery storage is going down approximately exponentially. The same can not be said for fossil fuel energy systems.
Well…I have to think, at some point, a gasoline car has caught fire. What with the multi-gallon tank full of explosives.
This sounds more like a problem with the fire suppression in the building. Wikipedia lists a few instances of electric cars catching alight in building but none where the building was destroyed[1].
Do you have a link to the news coverage of your incident so I can add it to Wikipedia?
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plug-in_electric_vehicle_fire_...
Re:Tesla Earning Result 3Q 2020 [pdf]
by Swenrekcah on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:36PM
(#24852998)
I think there will be a strong push for upgrading all outlets in garages to support charging an EV. Like you point out it is dangerous to charge without the proper equipment.
Gas powered cars also catch on fire and burn way more often than battery powered ones do, yet it isn't in the news because it is common.
Re:Tesla Earning Result 3Q 2020 [pdf]
by colinmhayes on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:06PM
(#24852752)
Gas cars are destroying the planet. They are much much less safe.
EDIT: Burning electric vehicles are much harder to put down than, say gas cars, because, for one they don't need external source of oxygen, and second, there's much more of fuel to burn: 1200 lbs of batteries in a Tesla vs 10 gallons (85 lbs) of gas in the tank of an average car. Electric cars will probably be banned from underground parkings, sooner or later.
And saying that gas cars are "destroying the planet" is just ridiculous - they are maybe 5% of total CO2 emissions. And electric cars are actually responsible for even more emissions - not from burning fuel, obviously, but just manufacturing it releases more carbon dioxide than an average gas-powered car will in its 25 years lifecycle.