News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Earning Result 3Q 2020 [pdf] by Hypx on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @05:01PM (#24852140)
A long running problem with Tesla. Their accounting has always smelled, and this has only gotten worse with every passing quarter.
Re:Tesla Earning Result 3Q 2020 [pdf] by edmundsauto on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @05:51PM (#24852631)
I'm not much of a financial guy, could you spell out the specifics in their accounting that smell? And whether this is a standard practice?
Re:Tesla Earning Result 3Q 2020 [pdf] by Hypx on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:58PM (#24853202)
A large number of "this doesn't quite add up" type of problems, as well as quarter to quarter inconsistencies.

For instance, accounts receivables goes up basically every quarter, but the reason for it always changes. People suspect large-scale fleet sales are being hidden in this term.

Plus their general dishonesty in how they are presenting numbers. They're greatly downplaying how all profits are coming from credit sales, and use an unusual definitions of "gross margin" which doesn't include R&D and sales related costs.

Re:Tesla Earning Result 3Q 2020 [pdf] by edmundsauto on Thursday October 22, 2020 @03:57PM (#24862662)
Is it dishonesty in the sense of “this is not an accepted accounting practice”? Or is it more “I don’t think this should be acceptable as an accounting practice”?

Genuinely curious, not much of a finance person.

Re:Tesla Earning Result 3Q 2020 [pdf] by Hypx on Friday October 23, 2020 @02:06AM (#24866462)
The central point of proper accounting is that it prevents frauds, scams, Ponzi schemes, or other nonsensical companies from existing. Companies that feel free to abandon those principles are inviting the possibility of becoming one of those kinds of companies.

In other words, it's a purely utilitarian argument. If Tesla is abandoning basic honesty in its accounting, then it's likely that there will come a day where, almost out of nowhere, the company collapses. We saw this with Wirecard recently, so this is not a unrealistic claim. This is arguably the worse possible outcome of an investment.

My own views are very much secondary to what could happen if this continues. You should view this problem entire on the premise of what the real-world risks are, and how it could affect investors.