Re:Blockchain, the Solution for Almost Nothing
by smt88 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @11:23PM
(#24844481)
I think you're creating a straw man here. No one is saying that the only two investment options are Bitcoin and stock. There are literally millions of other investment vehicles, from real estate to cattle to Legos.
You also have to acknowledge that most people don't pick stocks. They have exposure to the stock market indirectly through pension funds, or they manage their retirement funds by investing in ETFs.
If your ETF is sufficiently broad, you're not really betting on a single thing. Buying crypto is betting on the liquidity of that coin (or equity in a company or whatever the coin was made to track).
Buying a stock is betting on the dividends of that stock.
Buying industry-wide or nationwide index funds is betting on the long-term stability of society. If that society crashes (due to war, a pandemic, or climate change), you're probably screwed anyway because, well, your entire society has crashed.
Perhaps you could argue that investing in crypto is the opposite bet -- that society will crash in our lifetimes -- but it seems unpalatable to most people to bet on a Mad Max-like future for themselves at an old age and for their children.
You also have to acknowledge that most people don't pick stocks. They have exposure to the stock market indirectly through pension funds, or they manage their retirement funds by investing in ETFs.
If your ETF is sufficiently broad, you're not really betting on a single thing. Buying crypto is betting on the liquidity of that coin (or equity in a company or whatever the coin was made to track).
Buying a stock is betting on the dividends of that stock.
Buying industry-wide or nationwide index funds is betting on the long-term stability of society. If that society crashes (due to war, a pandemic, or climate change), you're probably screwed anyway because, well, your entire society has crashed.
Perhaps you could argue that investing in crypto is the opposite bet -- that society will crash in our lifetimes -- but it seems unpalatable to most people to bet on a Mad Max-like future for themselves at an old age and for their children.