Does hacking dilute creativity?
Hey guys,
Up until now I've been on the business side of things, but have now decided to learn to hack so that I can build my own ideas as soon as they come. However, even though I really enjoy programming, I feel that it somehow constricts my flow of ideas. Instead of pondering about whats possible, I now feel less creative as I feel the need to 'stay within the lines' of programming.
Has anybody else felt that hacking dilutes their creativity? If so, does this go away as your hacking skills progress?
(
4 comments
| 7 points
| on HN
)
I do have that problem to some extent myself. Sometimes building something really shows you new insight into a problem or system, but other times it ends up being 90% drudge work of the "accidental complexity" variety.
One approach to mitigate it is to try to find a lightweight prototyping process you can use, where you still actually write functioning code, but hopefully in a way that's less constraining. This is particularly useful if your "real" code is tied up in frameworks and Enterprisey architecture, which tend to be hard-to-steer ships.
Many parts of the Lisp and Python communities consider ease of open-ended, exploratory programming one of their main goals, so you might find something useful there. Prototyping the core ideas in some simpler way can also help; e.g. a lot of game designers will test out mechanics ideas by building little 2d demos where triangles interact with squares, even if the real game isn't going to look like a 2d abstract game.
I'm on the business side of things as well and I started learning PHP last year while freelancing and then switched over to Rails when I started my work with a Rails dev shop.
I have found that the process is that I dream up an idea, figure out how to code it, and repeat either step as necessary. Sometimes you have to tweak, sometimes you have to redo, but I have never really felt the constraints of my ability to code as a limitation to my creativity.
It becomes easier as you get better. :)
EDIT: I have also found that it helps for me to create a lean canvas for my projects - the money aspect is somewhat important, and it helps me figure out the MVP of a product so that I don't slave away for weeks on a non-profitable idea.
http://www.leancanvas.com
But yeah, you might feel constrained for a while until you master the tools. Once you do master them though, will anyone be able to tell you that your idea can't be implemented?
EDIT: i think that's also why you often hear the phrase "pushing the boundaries" in relation to creativity. Society is a constraint of a sort.