Re:Will the Next Zuckerberg Be a Designer, not a Hacker?
by qq66 on Monday April 25, 2011 @09:42PM
(#2483668)
Zuckberg IS a designer. Facebook gained massive initial traction not because it was technologically superior to other options (although it eventually ended up being so), but because it was very well thought out from a product perspective.
Re:Will the Next Zuckerberg Be a Designer, not a Hacker?
by neworbit on Monday April 25, 2011 @10:14PM
(#2483733)
The UX of Facebook beats the pants off Myspace, but still... doesn't strike me as a triumph of design. Though to be fair this may just be because things break more readily at a half billion users.
Re:Will the Next Zuckerberg Be a Designer, not a Hacker?
by qq66 on Monday April 25, 2011 @11:32PM
(#2483887)
By design I don't mean rounded corners and typography -- I mean things like limiting the networks to universities to begin with, having the Facebook graph mirror real-life social networks, the timing and characteristics of News Feed, Platform, Connect, etc.
Re:Will the Next Zuckerberg Be a Designer, not a Hacker?
by neworbit on Monday April 25, 2011 @11:59PM
(#2483934)
Oh, ok. The article seems to be talking about designers as the user-centric UX guys, or at least that's how I took it. I believe that this is critical to mainstream adoption, but agree that your point is excellent as well.
Re:Will the Next Zuckerberg Be a Designer, not a Hacker?
by mitko on Tuesday April 26, 2011 @12:07AM
(#2483949)
IMHO, the early Facebook was much better designed for one purpose (flirting and hooking up with members of the opposite sex), the current version is decently designed for multiple purposes (online identity, social games, etc...)
Re:Will the Next Zuckerberg Be a Designer, not a Hacker?
by rch on Monday April 25, 2011 @10:29PM
(#2483763)
MySpace failed by assuming that legions of random users would make intelligent design decisions, and giving them control over major style elements. The result being that users would receive a visual kick in the teeth every time they followed a link to a different user's page.
So, while FB certainly profited from that failure, but I wouldn't say that FB actively competed with a consciously superior design.
Re:Will the Next Zuckerberg Be a Designer, not a Hacker?
by qq66 on Tuesday April 26, 2011 @05:31AM
(#2484525)
I guess I have a different view of UX designers than some... I think of UX designer as basically the "designer of the experience that users will have..." effectively the entire product manager minus any monetization efforts. I use "UI designer" to mean graphics etc.
Re:Will the Next Zuckerberg Be a Designer, not a Hacker?
by RyanGWU82 on Monday April 25, 2011 @10:15PM
(#2483735)
By that logic, doesn't a hacker lack the skills that designers and only designers possess?
The whole dichotomy is silly. A tech business needs to figure out what to build, to build it, and to sell it. (Not strictly in that order.) Every one of those steps requires cross-functional thinking.
Re:Will the Next Zuckerberg Be a Designer, not a Hacker?
by ashgoblue on Monday April 25, 2011 @11:41PM
(#2483906)
I think designers will play a bigger role in founding teams in the future as products need to be designed for various platforms such as touch tablets, browser based web apps, mobile devices, etc. Each will require a unique set of interactions and design elements.
Re:Will the Next Zuckerberg Be a Designer, not a Hacker?
by dasil003 on Monday April 25, 2011 @10:57PM
(#2483806)
False dichotomy. What's happening now is that the barriers to both fields are being lowered, and the youth coming up today has the opportunity to become adept at both from an early age.
Granted, both fields require different thought processes and it's rare if not impossible to be truly great in both, but that's not what a startup needs. A startup needs a decent idea, fast execution, and hustle at all levels. Two things that factor very little into developing traction are stunning design and impeccable engineering. You want something that works and looks decent, but it's more important to move quickly and achieve product-market fit.
Re:Will the Next Zuckerberg Be a Designer, not a Hacker?
by nicetryguy on Tuesday April 26, 2011 @11:24AM
(#2485602)
Lest we forget, the reason Facebook took off in the first place is Privacy.
The design changed every six months or so.
Ideas are a dime a dozen. To start a company such as Facebook, you must have an intimate knowledge with how your product works. A 'Hacker' implies that someone knows the internals of their program, a 'Designer' implies they know how to make it look and feel nice.
The Hacker mentality works great for leading a company, knowing the ins and outs and possible future situations. The Designer mentality does not, making it look and feel nice.
Re:Will the Next Zuckerberg Be a Designer, not a Hacker?
by tuhin on Tuesday April 26, 2011 @03:19AM
(#2484278)
The next big guy (let's not make the poor guy/girl follow someone else's legacy) can be anybody who is great in either of Design, Programming or Business and practically capable (if not 10X) in the other two.
If you are just a great hacker, you CANNOT be the next thing.
If you are just a designer, you CANNOT be the next big thing.
And likewise.
Assumption: You do not have a team/cofounder that/who compliments your skills totally and share the same vision.
Re:Will the Next Zuckerberg Be a Designer, not a Hacker?
by rch on Monday April 25, 2011 @10:21PM
(#2483747)
Seems like there is an anecdote somewhere about how, in the early days of Google, an anonymous user would occasionally send the developers a message that simply stated the number of elements (words/links/whatever) on the main page, whenever that number went up. The developers took the implicit message to heart and endeavored to keep the noise to an absolute minimum.
Do you need to be a designer to realize that simplicity is a virtue?
Re:Will the Next Zuckerberg Be a Designer, not a Hacker?
by igorgue on Tuesday April 26, 2011 @03:22AM
(#2484281)
I think that the mindset of Zuckerberg or the next Zuckerberg will be the one of a hacker. Making him/her in fact a hacker.
What I'm trying to say is: Designers are hackers not in the software engineering point of view but in the problem solvers one.
In my opinion he was successful early on not because of his exceptional programming skills (although nobody said Facebook is the easiest thing to develop), but because his "Product Designer" skills.
Re:Will the Next Zuckerberg Be a Designer, not a Hacker?
by mkramlich on Tuesday April 26, 2011 @12:01AM
(#2483940)
Funny thing is that, especially early, Facebook didn't require particularly good programming skills. But it did have a much better and more professional, less sleazy (MySpace) or nerdy (LiveJournal) -looking UI than it's competitors/progenitors did. And then grew in a very intelligent and calculated away (Harvard first, then other Ivy League, then other colleges, etc.; and refusing to commercialize the experience too early). All of that really had nothing to do with the quality of the code or the main coder behind it (Zuck). Quality of the designer (arguably, especially early on: Zuck) and strategic direction (Zuck again?), but not of the hacking.
So, while FB certainly profited from that failure, but I wouldn't say that FB actively competed with a consciously superior design.
The whole dichotomy is silly. A tech business needs to figure out what to build, to build it, and to sell it. (Not strictly in that order.) Every one of those steps requires cross-functional thinking.
Granted, both fields require different thought processes and it's rare if not impossible to be truly great in both, but that's not what a startup needs. A startup needs a decent idea, fast execution, and hustle at all levels. Two things that factor very little into developing traction are stunning design and impeccable engineering. You want something that works and looks decent, but it's more important to move quickly and achieve product-market fit.
The design changed every six months or so.
Ideas are a dime a dozen. To start a company such as Facebook, you must have an intimate knowledge with how your product works. A 'Hacker' implies that someone knows the internals of their program, a 'Designer' implies they know how to make it look and feel nice.
The Hacker mentality works great for leading a company, knowing the ins and outs and possible future situations. The Designer mentality does not, making it look and feel nice.
The next Zuckerberg will be a hacker.
If you are just a great hacker, you CANNOT be the next thing. If you are just a designer, you CANNOT be the next big thing. And likewise.
Assumption: You do not have a team/cofounder that/who compliments your skills totally and share the same vision.
Do you need to be a designer to realize that simplicity is a virtue?
What I'm trying to say is: Designers are hackers not in the software engineering point of view but in the problem solvers one.
In my opinion he was successful early on not because of his exceptional programming skills (although nobody said Facebook is the easiest thing to develop), but because his "Product Designer" skills.