News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by wildmanx on Monday October 19, 2020 @03:06PM (#24829719)
Morally, taking that hormone is still wrong. And so should it be according to the rules too.

If you now answer that it's unfair that the person with naturally occurring higher levels can have it but those with lower levels can't "level" the playing field, well, tough luck. That's just the lottery that gives some people an advantage in certain sports. We all accept that some people are naturally tall and therefore have advantages in basketball. Or some people have naturally stronger VO2 max and thereby advantages in endurance sports.

The competition is how far you can get with the _natural state_ of your body, plus training. Not how far you can get as long as everybody pumps some substances up to a previously-agreed-upon threshold. Those thresholds are just the sad plan-B solution of anti-doping agencies if they can't directly measure doping substances and need to resort to measuring the effects instead. That actually disadvantages those with naturally higher effects.

Nobody would think of restricting maximum leg length, and as long as your legs are not longer than that it's fine to surgically extend them.

Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by the-dude on Monday October 19, 2020 @03:08PM (#24829745)
So why do we have different leagues for men and women then?
Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by wildmanx on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @02:47AM (#24834522)
To allow half the planet's population to also be competitive in sports. And often times, the style/technique slightly differs between them too.

In some sports you even have different weight classes. Rowing has 2, wrestling has 6 (olympic), boxing has 8-10 (olympic). The techniques there also differ slightly.

And there are other partitionings of the population too that restrict in who can participate in a competition. You have world championships, but you also have nationals. And regional competitions. And junior leagues. And school competitions.

Then there is also the paralympics.

You can find all that reasonable or ridiculous, but I'm not sure how that's related to doping.

Re:Chess’s Cheating Crisis by Hyolobrika on Monday October 19, 2020 @06:09PM (#24831584)
Good question