1) all platforms are acting against misinformation- singularly around the US elections mind you -
2) misinformation will be political, since it will impact one party or the other.
3) making a decision to remove it will therefore be a political decision
So to avoid being labeled political, platforms should not remove misinformation?
Not sure how that computes.
Leaving misinformation up for people to beat with better info, empirically doesn’t work. Social media has proven that at least, COVID and mask wearing is notable but only the most recent illustrative example.
So what should platforms do? Or maybe someone can outline a way to depoliticize such decisions?
Well yes. If you want to edit what your user post, you're not a platform anymore but an editor.
As much as I despise what Twitter did, I've been thinking about it for a couple of days and feel that the best option is a large number of strong Twitter competitors, rather than specific regulation. The slippery slope going the other way (silencing platforms) is just as bad as the one we're on. Throw the baby out with the bathwater.
Problem is you run into a physical limit at that point, there's only so many social media platforms we can be on, so creating such competition would be... hard... at this point.
And last time around, how did they handle the claims that were leaked from the Steele dossier?
The problem is that this sort of censorship is almost impossible to apply fairly. When your workforce is dominated by one political viewpoint, you are inevitably going to be biased in a way that a “platform” should not be.
It seems fairly obvious to anyone paying attention that their actions were politically-motivated and have been for quite some time.
Oh, and Trump is a serial liar who has spread really damaging lies via twitter ... numerous times.
As it stands, there is no reason to believe that it is fake.
If a publisher is also a platform, then they have different roles and responsibilities for each.
It's interesting to observe that he claims to be targeting Twitter with a defamation suit. I believe S230 would block that.
Under Twitter's behavior prior to about this year, they would have let unfiltered defamatory tweets go through without any fact-checking. Fact-checking may actually have saved this young man some malignedly-lost reputation had it existed at the time.
As a pure publisher, I think it's generally understood, there is inherent bias.
Indeed, even when people assume they're neutral, that assumption doesn't extend to full laissez-faire. All these platforms have basic "censorship" in place for legal compliance (DMCA takedown processes, interactions with government anti-crime systems, a need to follow US law regarding dissemination of pedophilic content, etc.).
Maybe because one can have extreme political views and easily find other like-minded people then one can become somewhat blinkered? If one's platform of choice is also stifling some content there is still enough of other stuff around that one may not notice?
Why shouldn't that matter, if Twitter also cares about its reputation?