Re:Starting a physical product company? You’re gonna need a ...
by p1necone on Monday October 19, 2020 @03:37AM
(#24824069)
That kind of incremental improvement strikes me as the sort of thing that shouldn't be patentable. Can you really patent "changing the physical dimensions a bit so it fits better"?
Re:Starting a physical product company? You’re gonna need a ...
by bdowling on Monday October 19, 2020 @04:21AM
(#24824263)
> That kind of incremental improvement strikes me as the sort of thing that shouldn't be patentable.
It is. Almost all patented inventions are improvements of other inventions. Foundational new technologies are a rare exception.
> Can you really patent "changing the physical dimensions a bit so it fits better"?
It depends. If the claimed dimensions were new and non-obvious, then maybe. The obviousness analysis would depend on the particular facts of the case and could be quite complex. The questions would probably be ones like, “Would a person having ordinary skill in the art be able to discover the claimed dimensions without undue experimentation?” or “Do the claimed dimensions provide an unexpected result?” or “Does the prior art ‘teach away’ from selecting the claimed dimensions?” So, again, it depends.
My grandma used to have the old ones when I visited as a kid. It's been a really long time, but I think the originals had deeper slots and the actual chips were a bit thinner. By making the slots shallower and the chips thicker they'd be less prone to bending which prevented them from fitting perfectly perpendicular after a bit of wear.