News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dr. Stallman responded to my open letter by bane on Monday April 25, 2011 @05:43AM (#2480864)
Our issue with Stallman is us expecting something of him that he's not the appropriate person to give.

Stallman is a seed planter, he's come up with a powerful pure idea, planted the seed, and now years later most people agree that many of these ideas have merit -- the world is a better place with free software.

Now that we've all caught on (or so we think) to this idea, we want Stallman to pragmatically carry it forward, to grow the movement. But to do so, you have to acknowledge certain, impure realities about Free software in the real world. Stallman, as essentially a theoretician, is not the right person to acknowledge those things. The real world gets messy, growing a movement involves marshaling conflicting people, it involves Politics.

Stallman doesn't get Politics, he's not a pragmatist, it's not in his blood and he's just not the right person to take his idea past seed planting into orchard growing. It takes a completely different kind of person. Expecting to be anything more than what he is will only ever leave one disappointed.

Re:Dr. Stallman responded to my open letter by drzaiusapelord on Monday April 25, 2011 @11:25AM (#2481523)
Stallman isn't the tide that raises all boats. Before the GPL we had the BSD licence and when I was a kid, things were just put into the public domain.

I think its very arguable if RMS and his group had anything to do with OSS success. Their attempt to build HURD is a huge failure and Linus's success may have more to do with his better management skills and the desire to build a free OS and an easy way to collaborate.

Re:Dr. Stallman responded to my open letter by bane on Monday April 25, 2011 @11:49AM (#2481618)
Before the GPL we had the BSD licence and when I was a kid, things were just put into the public domain.

That's really a great point. I've found Stallman's remarks about those alternate takes on Free (non-GPL, but also open source) rather off-putting and frankly silly myself. Some of his responses remind me of this scene

http://www.viddler.com/explore/loopytube/videos/819/

Re:Dr. Stallman responded to my open letter by tjr on Monday April 25, 2011 @12:20PM (#2481778)
Certainly free software existed before GNU. Most software was free software for years. Project GNU was started in an effort to proactively continue the tradition of free software in a computing world that was increasingly proprietary.