News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by gus_massa on Thursday October 15, 2020 @09:03PM (#24796284)
The anomalous heating is very difficult to measure and it is not going to convince anyone.

The new elements they got, are much more interesting. The problem is that:

* Cooper and Zinc that are the parts of brass.

* Iron, Chrome and Manganese that are common in stainless steel.

So the most simple explanation is contamination from the surrounding vessel and plumbing.

It is also very strange that they didn't get Cadmium and Indium that are the direct product of fusion of Palladium and Silver with Hydrogen, Deuterium and Helium. It is like if there was a fusion and then the new atom split into smaller atoms like all the ones I listed before. It is strange.

Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by raducu on Thursday October 15, 2020 @10:19PM (#24796747)
Shouldn't there be some kind of radiation detectable if fusion did occur?
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by robocat on Thursday October 15, 2020 @11:26PM (#24797152)
It could easily be that the radiation is well below the noise floor for background radiation or cosmic rays. The experiment doesn’t allow for selecting the type of radiation, and if the fusion is different from normal then the signature could be strange.

Detecting elements can be done for incredibly small amounts, but instead the problem is avoiding contamination.

Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by gnufx on Friday October 16, 2020 @04:40AM (#24798865)
It's a characteristic of this stuff claiming to be doing nuclear physics that you actually avoid real nuclear physics (gamma and neutron detection) and possibly hand-wave it away like that. I used to study sub-barrier fusion reactions with palladium and sensitive detectors, and all this business was risible from the start.
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by lumost on Friday October 16, 2020 @10:14AM (#24800991)
There's a non zero chance that the transmutations would also be due to cosmic rays.
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by dumbfoundded on Thursday October 15, 2020 @09:13PM (#24796355)
The odds that cold fusion has been discovered are 0.
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by beervirus on Friday October 16, 2020 @12:33AM (#24797494)
Lattice assisted nuclear reactions exist. They just don't generate usable amounts of power.
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by gus_massa on Friday October 16, 2020 @09:46AM (#24800770)
> Lattice assisted nuclear reactions exist.

"Lattice assisted nuclear reactions" is just another name for "cold fusion" (or perhaps a branch of "cold fusion"). All the papers published about this have been unconvincing.

> They just don't generate usable amounts of power.

All the papers I remember report an small excess of heat. The problem is that heat is very difficult to measure accurately (the different parts of the equipment have different temperatures, estimating the heat transported in convection is a mess, some chemical parts may react, ...)

Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by lumost on Friday October 16, 2020 @10:26AM (#24801087)
There are strong theoretical grounds for lattice assisted fusion. The metal lattice acts to screen the deuterium atoms, and the lattice increases the overall cross section.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01685...

Unfortunately no practical mechanism for creating a self sustaining reaction has been proposed. Although the theoretical benefit has been demonstrated by heating the fuel via hot neutron bombardment.

https://journals.aps.org/prc/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevC.101.0...

Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by gus_massa on Friday October 16, 2020 @03:34PM (#24804214)
The articles are interesting, but in both case it is not enough the 400°C that they used in this experiment.

I think that "cold fusion" is not theoretically impossible. For comparison, "high temperature superconductivity" is also weird, and in 1985 any result about it would have been received with a big dose od skepticism. The problem is that "cold fusion" has a very bad track record in the last years.

Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by jacobwilliamroy on Thursday October 15, 2020 @09:39PM (#24796511)
I really think cold fusion is a prank. Like when my dad would send me out to buy "headlight fluid" just to mess with me.
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by dumbfoundded on Thursday October 15, 2020 @09:51PM (#24796584)
I think it's like trying to prove P = NP. Maybe it's technically possible, but no one in their right mind thinks it's going to happen.
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by jacobwilliamroy on Thursday October 15, 2020 @10:46PM (#24796918)
As far as I can tell, the only reason cold fusion is even a thing is because someone published a paper that has never been reproduced. P=NP is at least possible: it has to be true or untrue. I'm not even sure if our current understand of physics even supports cold fusion.

I guess maybe it does seeing as how I got downvoted? Presumably by amazing scientists who have developed cold fusion technology? Or at least have a theory of how it could happen in our universe?

Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by Retric on Thursday October 15, 2020 @10:50PM (#24796946)
Muon-catalyzed fusion is beloved to be physically possible at room temperature though as the catalyst has a half life of ~ 2.2 microseconds that’s not practical. But as far as we know cold fusion as described in the original paper is simply a mistake in the original experiment.
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by hansvm on Friday October 16, 2020 @01:59AM (#24797938)
Fwiw, P=NP could be independent from our current commonly used axioms; it doesn't have to be purely true or false.
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by versteegen on Friday October 16, 2020 @03:31AM (#24798487)
My understanding is it's necessarily either true or false, but may not be provably true or false. This could allow us to actually have an algorithm that solves all NP problems in P time, but ZFC can't prove it works for all inputs.

Edit: So in that case, what would it mean to add an axiom that P=NP? See https://mathoverflow.net/questions/50023/independence-of-p-n... especially the answer by Andreas Blass. Basically, you could add axioms that change the meaning of 'Turing machine' (ie 'computation') by changing the meaning of 'natural number' resulting in an algorithm witnessing P=NP that maybe can't be run on physical computers.

Way off topic...

Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by hansvm on Friday October 16, 2020 @11:49AM (#24801982)
Agreed, definitely off topic. Fun to consider anyway :)

Without considering many facts specific to P=NP, it could be feasible for it to neither true nor false in ZFC (i.e., some model of ZFC has P=NP, and some other has P!=NP), in which case you could take P=NP as another axiom. Other statements that work this way include the continuum hypothesis.

If I'm not mistaken (and misstatements regarding P=NP are common, so don't take this blindly), P=NP has a substantial amount of additional structure to it due to it being a low-complexity arithmetical statement. In particular, I believe you're correct that in ZFC it is actually either true or false in all models, but not necessarily provably so from within ZFC. In this case you could try to take it as an axiom (e.g. ZFC+PNP), but you'd either wind up with ZFC itself or an inconsistent axiom set.

As a related (maybe equivalent?) statement, P=NP has the property that if A is an axiom independent from ZF and P=NP (resp P!=NP) is provable in ZF+A then P=NP (resp P!=NP) is provable in ZF, again due to its nature as a low-complexity arithmetical statement, so either P=NP is unprovable in any meaningful extension of ZF, or it's provable in all of them.

Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by pfdietz on Friday October 16, 2020 @07:11AM (#24799602)
The weird thing about the field is that a negative result should REDUCE the estimate of how likely something is. And yet, after P&F, people took it more seriously.
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by nextaccountic on Saturday October 17, 2020 @03:09AM (#24808035)
P&F?
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium by pfdietz on Saturday October 17, 2020 @06:47AM (#24809061)
Pons and Fleischmann.