Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium
by cromwellian on Thursday October 15, 2020 @08:31PM
(#24796071)
But what about a control experiment? How about letting the PdAg sit in a vacuum for the same amount of time under similar conditions and see what develops? How do they rule out contamination, such as by cosmic rays?
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium
by AnimalMuppet on Thursday October 15, 2020 @08:38PM
(#24796121)
If I read the abstract right, they did in fact have a control. They had the exact same palladium/silver mix in it, but didn't cycle D2, H2, or He in and out. It wound up with much fewer of the surprising elements.
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium
by marcinzm on Thursday October 15, 2020 @10:30PM
(#24796824)
Couldn't that be explained by the cycling introducing contamination (ie: along with the D2, H2, He it also brought in a few other atoms from the plumping or whatever)?
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium
by Filligree on Thursday October 15, 2020 @10:38PM
(#24796871)
Easily.
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium
by jiggawatts on Friday October 16, 2020 @08:18AM
(#24800047)
But the "control" wasn't. It was a different coil, and they didn't characterise either of the coils' metallurgy prior to the experiment.
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium
by lumost on Friday October 16, 2020 @10:37AM
(#24801194)
The addition of deuterium will open new avenues for reactions by cosmic rays.
Re:Transmutations observed from pressure cycling palladium
by phkahler on Thursday October 15, 2020 @09:38PM
(#24796502)
>> I really wish they hadn’t been discounted as erroneous without attempts to replicate by the larger scientific community.
Sure. But what if LENR is real? They may be opening pandoras box.
I really wish they hadn’t been discounted as erroneous without attempts to replicate by the larger scientific community. We’d be much farther along by now, in capturing this extremely interesting result!