I too have perceived the excellence of OpenBSD. For instance, at Arbor Networks, I had the distinct pleasure of using OpenBSD to manage traffic flows from ISP backbones. When processes malloc'd over 64 megs of data, UVM deadlocked. After writing a passive kernel debugger using KVM to produce repro steps and diag dumps for their team, I was informed that Theo didn't really understand how Cranor's UVM worked, that it was crappy code from Cranor's thesis and all Cranor's fault, and that there was no way I would find anyone who could fix it.
There is indeed a lot Linux can learn from OpenBSD, but imitation is probably not the right way to go about it.
OpenBSD's track record on security is not unblemished.
i'm confused what your rant about theo is supposed to mean. you found a problem but didn't know how to fix it, so you presented it to theo and he said he didn't know how to fix it either? he didn't write the code in question and no one on the team (at the time) knew it well enough to change it. what's your point?
no one's security record is unblemished and i don't think anyone from the openbsd project would say it is.
The code in question was the virtual memory system. That's what UVM is.
Nobody at OpenBSD investigated the issue? Well, that's shocking. Their developers behave as assholes sometimes, but they don't ignore sensible bug reports.
I had problems with OpenBSD's UVM too, but it was a known issue and increasing NKMEMPAGES_MAX solved it.
OpenBSD mindset is to achieve security through excellence. Everyone can look at their code and perceive its quality: everything follows the same coding guidelines, it's well commented and easy to understand, every important commit in the CVS has to be reviewed by at least another commiter, errors are handled early... after looking at it, Linux looks a mess.
That obsession about security leads to a software product that shows robustness and quality. Yes, Linux outperforms OpenBSD in many areas, it has been ported to more architectures and has more functionalities. But, still, Linux could learn a lot about OpenBSD as a project.