News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by cletus on Sunday April 24, 2011 @12:47PM (#2479141)
This is a great headline-grabber but I still see landing a man on Mars as being an awful long way off.

I heard Jerry Pournelle talking about this and he said something like landing a man on the Moon and establishing a lunar colony is an engineering problem. Landing a man on Mars is a science problem.

The difference? We can already do the former. it's simply a question of money and the will to do it. The problems are basically solved.

Landing a man on Mars has far bigger problems. The round trip (or even one way) journey with current propulsion technology will take an incredibly long time (upwards of 2 years). How do you keep someone alive that long? What about the psychology of isolation? Sustained radiation exposure is a real problem.

Personally I see manned spaceflight, particularly to other planets, as being largely a propaganda exercise until:

1. The cost of lifting into orbit (per kg) goes down. Way down. Like 2 or even 3 orders of magnitude; and

2. We have a much faster means of propulsion to make journey lengths manageable.

(1) is probably the easiest to solve. SpaceX's launch prices are actually quite low (but those are fairly low orbits; launching to another planet is more expensive). Virgin Galactic and other private suborbital efforts will (hopefully) lead to a dramatic cost reduction of getting into orbit.

(2) is a fundamentally hard problem. Ideas such as solar sails and the like are far from being practical (plus with a solar sail, how do you get back?). Magnetic fields as solar sails is an interesting idea but has a whole bunch of other problems.

Otherwise you need to eject mass to give you velocity. That mass is something you have to carry. The more mass (fuel) you carry, the less effective each gram is (in delta-V terms).

What I think will probably drive this is the coming earthbound resource shortages (inevitable unless we drastically reduce population; it's simply a question of when) that will drive a permanent presence in space. Once you have a huge industrial manufacturing capacity in space, the economics completely change.

EDIT: I agree with other comments in that a one-way (colonization) mission makes far more sense but I'm still unconvinced this will happen anytime soon, probably not in my lifetime.

Mars does have some interesting properties though if a colony can become self-sustaining:

1. Lower gravity. This actually makes the idea of a space elevator far more feasible [1]; and

2. Mars has features that extend beyond the atmosphere. The atmosphere is ~11km thick. Olympus Mons is 25km high.

I've read seemingly informed speculation that if we (the human race) had evolved on Mars, we'd already be heavily spacebound since it would be far, far easier.

This is what might justify colonizing Mars. Not that that is an easy problem.

[1]: http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=95924

Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by bfe on Sunday April 24, 2011 @02:31PM (#2479349)
At this point, sending humans to Mars is also just an engineering problem, not a science problem.

The trip time using conventional chemical rockets is limited to modified Hohmann transfer orbits of around six to eight months each way, and the duration on the surface would be about eighteen months before the next orbital launch window between Earth and Mars. With basic well-understood radiation mitigation techniques, total radiation exposure for each astronaut over the duration of the mission is around 50 rem, less than the amount needed to increase by 1% the chances of a 35-year old adult of developing cancer at some point later in life, a lower risk than by spending the same amount of time smoking cigarettes on Earth.

Getting the astronauts back isn't prohibitively more difficult than getting them there in the first place: the energy expenditure for escaping the surface is 17% of the Earth's, and using the Mars Direct mission architecture, you can send a return vehicle ahead of time with seed hydrogen to manufacture liquid methane propellant and liquid oxygen oxidizer from the carbon dioxide air, through the Sabatier reaction for both and also with electrical dissociation of the carbon dioxide for more oxygen. You can also test it in flight after producing its fuel before deciding to launch the humans to Mars in the first place.

We still need a heavier-lift heavy lift vehicle of at least 100 to 140 tonnes to LEO to start being able to send major assets to the Mars surface in one shot, but SpaceX is becoming increasingly credible as a possible creator of such a vehicle. Putting humans on Mars within twenty years would require at least a few billion dollars a year (a small fraction of NASA's budget) and ironing out some engineering details, but is entirely doable. The biggest obstacle is just having leadership with a sustained focus on that goal over the course of the couple of decades required, and that hasn't been forthcoming from within government, but perhaps could be supplied from a private entity. SpaceX has been laying down a solid record of presenting visionary plans for spacefaring capabilities and then making them happen.

Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by FrojoS on Sunday April 24, 2011 @04:32PM (#2479560)
I second the first two paragraphs but I'm not sure about the third one.

I want to see a 140t to LEO rocket, too and I'm sure SpaceX is already building it.* However, is this really necessary? I think the orignal, soviet moon flight plan would have been to put several stages into LEO and combine them there. The plan was given up, but I think it should still be possible if no larger rocket is available soon. Consider, SpaceX plans to lunch 10 Flacon heavy (53t to LEO) per year at a combined cost of 800-1250 million.*

And of course, the Saturn V did already put 119t to LEO in 1967. Hence, their knowledge in building space stations like MIR. How much was bailing out those rust belt dinosaurs again?

Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by bfe on Sunday April 24, 2011 @06:51PM (#2479828)
Besides the added complexity of assembling components together in LEO, placing any mass into low Earth orbit is really inconsistent with putting it into a trans Mars trajectory and adds a giant extra delta-V penalty. It's a much different orbital inclination, plus there's the added energy loss of circularizing a trajectory into low-Earth orbit and later boosting out into a hyperbolic escape trajectory. As far as I understand it, it would be faster and cheaper to develop a true heavy lift launcher.
Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by lutorm on Sunday April 24, 2011 @08:50PM (#2480024)
Why do you say the inclination is different? You can go into LEO at any inclination.

I also don't see why you need more delta-v to go from launch orbit to circular orbit to transfer orbit compared to the transfer orbit directly. My orbital mechanics are rusty, but it seems to me that since you need to lift the perigee from Earth's surface to Mars orbit, you'll pass the circular orbit on the way.

Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by bfe on Monday April 25, 2011 @12:53AM (#2480463)
If you go into low Earth orbit from the Earth's surface, you need to go into an orbital inclination equal to the latitude of your launch site - which is extremely unhelpful if you want to then take that mass anywhere else in the solar system. You also need to circularize your orbit, then later boost that mass from circular orbit to hyperbolic escape orbit - also extremely wasteful.
Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by lutorm on Monday April 25, 2011 @09:53PM (#2483687)
Ok, good point about the inclination.

I still don't see why circularizing the orbit would be wasteful. Circularizing an elliptical orbit at apogee still requires positive delta-v, which will help you on the way to the hyperbolic orbit. Only if you want to circularize at perigee would you need to slow down, which would indeed be extremely wasteful. It's true that you get more energy boost for the delta-v if you do it early rather than late, but I don't know if the ellipticity of the launch orbit is high enough for that difference to qualify as "extremely" wasteful. But maybe it is.

Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by FrojoS on Sunday April 24, 2011 @07:10PM (#2479857)
True, a better Saturn V would be the best. I was just trying to think about, if for whatever reasons, a better rocket would not get ready in time. But maybe what I wrote was just plain bullshit. ;-) Of course it would make more sense to send all the small rockets towards mars at the same time and 'somehow' combine them but that doesn't sound easy either.
Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by tsotha on Sunday April 24, 2011 @08:04PM (#2479937)
Why bother putting it into a circular orbit? I don't see the point.

As I understand it the big drawback to EOR from an engineering standpoint is that the added complexity introduces a bunch of extra failure modes.

Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by Zaak on Sunday April 24, 2011 @09:11PM (#2480061)
If you boost something up to orbital velocity and LEO altitude but don't circularize, its orbit still intersects the atmosphere, if not the earth. The delta-v required to keep from falling back down would be better used to push into whatever transfer orbit you want.
Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by JoeAltmaier on Monday April 25, 2011 @09:16AM (#2481153)
Perhaps Don't assemble them - launch them separately and they arrive separately.
Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by FrojoS on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @10:53AM (#2489667)
To some extend thats of course possible. Wouldn't that be funny if in the end, all crew member travel separately because its cheaper? :-D Now thats isolation! At least they would have short latency when talking to each other.

Of course, once you've build a big enough rocket, its usually cheaper than multiple small ones. But there is a market for medium size rockets like the Falcon Heavy already. Not so, for bigger rockets - yet.

Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by drm237 on Sunday April 24, 2011 @01:00PM (#2479169)
I'm not sure we need to dramatically reduce the population in order for the Earth to sustain us, we just can't let it continue to grow unchecked forever.

According to the FAO, the earth could feed up to 12 billion people: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hunger#World_statistics

Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by abeppu on Sunday April 24, 2011 @01:47PM (#2479260)
But that's in terms of total agricultural output, under a scenario where you stop feeding a large portion of your crops to livestock, and where large amounts of food aren't wasted. The first line in the wiki article you link to mentions that roughly 1/6 of the planet is malnourished. The WFP says that ~6 million children die of malnutrition and hunger related diseases annually in developing countries. Meanwhile, the US feeds something like 90% of its soy, 80% of its corn and 70% of its other grain to livestock, much of which we kill for meat. This fact -- that the rich choose to consume luxury products with relatively large footprints in terms of limited resources, such as meat when the world's poorest are malnourished, or beer or consumer electronics when many have insufficient access to clean water -- makes me think that our future ability to sufficiently feed 9-10 billion people will be less a function our total agricultural resources, and more a function of the disparity between the rich and the poor.
Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by jacoblyles on Monday April 25, 2011 @02:04AM (#2480591)
As attractive as your logic sounds, it is wrong. If the rich world consumed fewer food resources, that would not mean the poor would eat more. There is not some fixed quantity of food that is distributed by some central zero-sum mechanism. Rather, malnourished people are malnourished because they live in areas with dysfunctional economies and governments. Producing food isn't the problem, distribution is.
Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by abeppu on Monday April 25, 2011 @01:14PM (#2482020)
I totally agree that the issue isn't producing food but rather distributing it process. I further agree that this isn't a strictly zero-sum mechanism.

But yeah, if rich people consumed fewer food resources, prices would drop, and some malnourished people who can't afford sufficient food now would be able to afford more. Blaming the problem on dysfunctional local economies and governments is facile way of absolving oneself of personal responsibility -- "My consumption of limited resources isn't the problem; it's corrupt governments. I can keep consuming however I like, comfortable in the knowledge that I'm not causing harm to anyone else". Yes, dysfunctional governments and economies in developing countries are part of the problem, and no matter what rich people do or do not consume, they probably won't help the hungry people in N. Korea by doing so. But there are plenty of places where that's not the case. The fact that the 2007-2008 food crisis did meaningfully impact a lot of people in developing countries should indicate that we are all connected to the same global food economy, and what we do with our agricultural resources in rich countries can and does impact the prices and availability in developing ones.

Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by cletus on Sunday April 24, 2011 @01:05PM (#2479186)
Food is the least of our problems.

Energy is a bigger problem. While we can make energy from renewable sources it is far more expensive (which has ramifications for our entire way of life) and not yet established that we could provide it on the scale necessary to replace our non-renewable sources.

But the biggest problem is resources. Metals, rare earth elements and the like. These are largely irreplaceable in the sense that we can produce so much of them by (typically) digging fairly shallow holes in the ground. We're already going to some fairly inhospitable places to meet our insatiable demand (eg the Arctic in northern Canada and Europe, the Andes).

If we're not careful we may well find our own answer to the Fermi paradox.

Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by evgen on Sunday April 24, 2011 @01:49PM (#2479262)
Actually, food is the only problem when it comes to whether or not a population is sustainable. Enery and resource usage determine if a particular lifestyle is sustainable for a given population. Given sufficient energy other resource problems tend to go away (e.g. the amount of various minerals that are in solution within the oceans is mind-boggling but it takes energy to get them out). In the end the lifestyle any particular population can sustain will come down to an energy production/capture and management problem.
Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by cletus on Sunday April 24, 2011 @02:05PM (#2479289)
> Energy and resource usage determine if a particular lifestyle is sustainable for a given population

And maintaining a particular lifestyle tends to be a strong catalyst for war as a means of solving population problems. The problem is we're now at a point where such a thing could be truly devastating.

While the threat of mutually-assured destruction has kept the specter of nuclear war at bay, I believe you'll see the means of destruction migrate to more fine-grained methods, most notably genetic engineering and nanotechnology, both of which will become increasingly accessible on a scale nuclear technology never has.

> Given sufficient energy other resource problems tend to go away

I agree but all the energy replacements in the foreseeable future will make energy more expensive not cheaper.

Fission-based energy has the same fuel problem fossil fuelds do (the unfulfilled promises of thorium reactors notwithstanding).

Fusion-based energy has huge problems, some of which are fairly fundamental and not likely to be solved anytime soon.

The most obvious problem (containment of plasma) is probably solvable with magnetism.

The bigger problem is neutrons. You currently can't leave a fusion reactor on for very long before it starts destroying its container.

He-3 (Helium-3) is one possibly solution to this but that stuff is incredibly rare and may well present the same fuel problems as any other energy source.

Interestingly there's a supply of it on the Moon due to billions of years of solar wind on an atmosphere-less body.

> In the end the lifestyle any particular population can sustain will come down to an energy production/capture and management problem.

With some fairly nasty corrections that may have undesirable consequences for the rest of us.

Anyway, that's why I say food is the least of our problems. We can already produce enough food for the present population. It's unclear how much longer we can support the lifestyle of that same population.

Energy factors in here too as we're now fairly distant from our food (given how urbanized the developed world generally is) but population redistribution will occur naturally as the energy equation changes.

Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by Mz on Sunday April 24, 2011 @03:30PM (#2479444)
Actually, food is the only problem when it comes to whether or not a population is sustainable. Enery and resource usage determine if a particular lifestyle is sustainable for a given population.

Food needs aren't static: They vary considerably from person to person and can be changed for a particular individual who sets out to change their lifestyle. Also, a lot of the energy that is currently being expended for transportation could be readily replaced by human energy if walking and biking became more popular -- which is both an energy issue and a lifestyle issue.

I currently live without a car and I have a medical condition that typically causes one to have a very high calorie need. I've worked hard on getting myself healthier and my calorie need has shrunk dramatically. In some ways it is counterintuitive, but living without a car has turned out to be an asset in that regard. Doing a lot of walking is one of the things that has helped me get healthier and shrink my calorie needs. Obesity is epidemic in the US and we do not have a very pedestrian-friendly environment. Most Americans seem unable to imagine living without a car.

So this assumption that energy and some kind of non-food fuel are separate from food and people just doesn't quite compute for me. They aren't totally separate issues. If people walked more and drove less, it would leave more gasoline and other fuel sources for other things and, at least in America, likely substantially lower food needs as well.

Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by cheez on Sunday April 24, 2011 @01:42PM (#2479252)
Nuke-u-ler.
Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by FrojoS on Sunday April 24, 2011 @04:17PM (#2479528)
I'm not a rocket scientist and you seem to be very knowledgeable. However, I feel like you are overstating the problems and should drink some of that "homo faber can do anything he/she wants" cool aid. ;-)

I mean, "psychology of isolation" come on! People have been in super tiny submarines for months, while water bombs are exploding around them all night long. And thats at least two generations ago.

I doubt that von Braun and co. had solved all the problems for flying to the moon, when Kennedy set the goal. I have no doubts that they would have put a man on Mars soon after, had the program continued. When the Saturn V was retired, humanity was put four decades back - and counting. Its only a question of will. Do we want to have nicer cars or advance the frontier of humanity?

Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by JshWright on Monday April 25, 2011 @09:36AM (#2481188)
Frankly? I'd vote for nicer cars...
Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by FrojoS on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @10:54AM (#2489681)
Thanks for that reply. Apparently you're not the only one. Personally I find this very sad, but I guess its just a matter of taste...
Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by joeyh on Sunday April 24, 2011 @02:59PM (#2479398)
I've read fairly convincing arguments that we don't know how to land on Mars, either. Problems of thin atmosphere, difficulties in aereobraking, etc. http://www.universetoday.com/25438/why-cant-we-land-on-mars/

Currently the method that's worked best is to bounce down a sturdy probe on giant balloons, and now NASA is trying a quite rube-goldberg lander that hangs below its retrorockets. Still very much in the experimenting phase.

Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by bfe on Sunday April 24, 2011 @04:31PM (#2479557)
It's true that using aerobraking alone for an incoming vessel from Earth landing on Mars would be infeasible. Landing with thrust, like we did on the Moon forty years ago, but also using assistance from aerobraking and parachutes, is not an issue.
Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by ugh on Sunday April 24, 2011 @08:17PM (#2479964)
Phoenix successfully landed and if the Mars Science Laboratory manages to land safely we might get ready to conclude that at least NASA has landing on Mars figured out.

It’s not really experimenting, NASA simply has progressively scaled up their landers. It’s hard but they know how to do it.

Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by benl on Monday April 25, 2011 @04:44AM (#2480806)
"plus with a solar sail, how do you get back?"

This is actually really simple and not a problem at all -- you just have to understand orbital mechanics a bit. Basically, you angle the solar sail so that its force is directed against your direction of travel along your orbit. This slows you down, causing you to start spiraling in toward the sun. Then you change angle so that you start speeding up again and match orbital velocities just as you arrive at your destination.

But it's a separate issue anyway -- solar sail technology (or Vasimir, or Nuclear Thermal) is no more required for exploring Mars than jet airplane technology was required for exploring North America.

Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by ANH on Sunday April 24, 2011 @06:13PM (#2479759)
plus with a solar sail, how do you get back?

Install reflectors on the surface of Mars, shine super-big lasers at Mars, sail home on reflected light.

Re:SpaceX aims to put man on Mars in 10-20 years by abeppu on Sunday April 24, 2011 @01:46PM (#2479256)
Can you expand on the resource shortages driving space settlement stuff? I'm curious what kind of resources you're thinking of.