Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting
by prawn on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @09:46PM
(#24783904)
Isn't it because a hack was involved?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting
by 101011 on Thursday October 15, 2020 @08:39AM
(#24787939)
The NYTimes just had a big scoop on Trump's tax returns.
Would it be considered a hack if somebody within the IRS gave those documents to the press? What if the source was a foreign entity working through an intermediary?
That is to say, what distinguishes a source vs a hack is a function of the press' investigation into the authenticity of the materials.
I'm not sure blocking the NYPost is the right call here, much as I hate to say it.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting
by Thorrez on Thursday October 15, 2020 @03:36AM
(#24785910)
What's the definition of hack? If we believe NY Post's story, did a hack happen? Or are we assuming NY Post's story is false, and the materials came from an unreported hack?
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting
by prawn on Thursday October 15, 2020 @03:56AM
(#24786004)
I was just going by Twitter's statement in response. Hadn't looked into it beyond that.
"Twitter blocked users from sharing an article that indicated Hunter Biden introduced his father Joe to a Ukranian businessman — charging that “hacked materials” were used in the story."
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting
by odessacubbage on Thursday October 15, 2020 @06:09AM
(#24786840)
the zimmerman telegraph and the pentegon papers could both be roughly described as 'hacked materials' i think most would agree they still fell firmly within the public interest.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting
by thu2111 on Thursday October 15, 2020 @08:32AM
(#24787894)
The NY Post states no hacking occurred and this allegation is itself "baseless". It appears Twitter/FB simply assumed it must be hacking so they could use trigger their anti-doxxing policies, as otherwise they'd have had no policies to block it, as it's clearly journalism. But if the NY Post are telling the truth then it's actually FB/Twitter spreading misinformation.
Very, very bad move by Twitter and Facebook. The partisan rule-bending is clear.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting
by tasogare on Thursday October 15, 2020 @12:31AM
(#24784947)
No it’s not. Had it been leaks concerning Trump collusion with Russian to rig previous election (you know, that fake news that runned for 4 years), it would have been placed in trending topic instead. GP is right, there is a very obvious double standard at play, and this is not happening only in the IS.