News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Linus Torvalds on security by tptacek on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @02:59PM (#247836)
That's not a very valid point. None of the boring normal bugs cost my mom her credit score or, for the months it takes to resolve the problem, her savings account balance. There has also never ever ever been an X11 bug that took down the Internet.

There is also a CS-theoretic difference between "all the boring normal bugs" that emerge during variations of normal use cases, and the much larger, much harder to model class of byzantine failures that occur only when components of the system are forced to operate at odds with the the system as a whole. Security failures are byzantine failures. They are, at the very least, extremely difficult to predict and plan for.

Re:Linus Torvalds on security by dominik on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @03:05PM (#247842)
From what I've seen, most security bugs chain a few normal bugs together. One oversight here, another there, combine them and you have an exploit.

The valid point I think Linus is getting at (perhaps I'm reading too much into it) is that if you solve normal, boring bugs, you prevent the much trumpeted security bugs from ever coming out. By heaping praise on the security team and ignoring the careful programmer who writes good code and eliminates bugs before they exist, Linus sees the community move towards a crisis-solving mode rather than a crisis-prevention mode. His view is that it's far better to focus on writing good, solid code that tests robustly rather than hyper-focusing on security at the cost of everything else. This is not to dismiss the importance of security; instead, it is a fundamental focus shift -- thus the example of OpenBSD, where Linus sees security paranoia has subsumed everything else.

Re:Linus Torvalds on security by tptacek on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @03:13PM (#247854)
The valid point you're making is not Linus', it's Theo's.

It's OpenBSD's approach --- and they pioneered it --- that "all bugs are eventually exploitable". That dogma, which some people say has served them well, contributes to the impression that OpenBSD is (1) fascistic about technical matters that at first glance seem more about vanity than about security, and (2) hypocritical in the extreme about what actually happens in their codebase.

What Linus is saying really doesn't have anything to do with security. What he's saying is, "my job is to improve Linux, and if you give me a valid bugfix, I will treat it the same way I treat any other important bug".

Re:Linus Torvalds on security by dominik on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @03:58PM (#247914)
Ah, thanks for the clarification.

I read too much into Linus's words.