News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Linus Torvalds on security by tptacek on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @02:56PM (#247834)
The fundamental dispute here is that security researchers want Linus to take a vow of silence on any bug they report to him, which vow extends all the way into how Linus manages the git repositories.

Look, there are two ways to read this comment from Linus.

On the one hand, there's the batshit crazy read, which sincerely believes that data theft, fraud, and privacy violations are on equal footing with performance, reliability, or even data corruption problems. The difference between security flaws and bugs is that bugs don't have adversaries behind them.

But all that really tells us is that Linus has never talked to anybody who worked for a bank.

On the other hand, there's the weary pragmatist's read, which understands what 15 years of withering pompousness from security experts takes out of a development team. These are people who not only want their bugs at the front of the line, but have talking points for Linus to adhere to at the same time.

It's refreshing to see him tell my industry to fuck off. We deserve it.

T'so has the final, true, correct read on this. It's not Linus' job to manage Linux security. There are hundreds of people better situated to do that job. If you don't want Linus spilling the beans on your press release advisory, don't let Linus find out about it. Problem solved.

Re:Linus Torvalds on security by cperciva on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @03:06PM (#247843)
If you don't want Linus spilling the beans on your press release advisory, don't let Linus find out about it. Problem solved.

In fact, Linus has specifically said in the past that he does not want to be told about security issues. If you find a security issue in the linux kernel, report it to vendor-sec.

Re:Linus Torvalds on security by tptacek on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @03:07PM (#247846)
That's not true. Reporting vulnerabilities to vendor-sec enrolls you in the politics of vendor security, which many reasonable people could make a case for avoiding. Linus isn't saying "don't tell me about your security problems". He's saying "take your talking points and shove them up your ass". On that one single point, he's absolutely right.
Re:Linus Torvalds on security by cperciva on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @03:47PM (#247897)
Reporting vulnerabilities to vendor-sec enrolls you in the politics of vendor security, which many reasonable people could make a case for avoiding.

Responsible disclosure, i.e., making sure that fixes are ready before an issue is announced, requires vendor coordination. The politics is unavoidable if you want to do things right -- although, speaking as someone who is on vendor-sec, the politics really is rather minimal these days.

Linus isn't saying "don't tell me about your security problems".

I didn't claim that he was saying that today. I said that in the past he has said that.

Re:Linus Torvalds on security by tptacek on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @04:31PM (#247930)
"Responsible disclosure" is a marketing term. Linus may be wrong about the importance of security flaws relative to bugs, but that doesn't validate the self-aggrandizing omerta of security researchers.

Vendor "coordination" of security flaws often works to the detriment of users. For one thing, cliques like vendor-sec gossip and share findings with the "cool kids", ensuring that every interested party but the operators knows what's coming a week before the advisories are published. For another, it substitutes the judgement of people like you --- who, no offense, don't run real world systems or make real world risk assessments about real assets --- for the judgement of the people who are not like you, but who could potentially disable or work around vulnerable systems far in advance of "coordinated patches".

PS: "I said in the past, not today!" --- if you believe in what you're saying, say it and then defend it with evidence. But don't slam competing projects just because you think nobody's going to call you on it, Colin.

Re:Linus Torvalds on security by huhtenberg on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @08:37PM (#248114)
Hmm .. I have hard time believing that you are not twisting or misinterpreting what he said. Can you source the quote please ?

Especially considering what he said regarding the vendor-sec -

  I refuse to have anything to even _do_ with organizations 
  like vendor-sec that I think is a corrupt cluster-fuck of
  people who just want to cover their own ass.
http://thread.gmane.org/gmane.linux.kernel/701694/focus=7069...
Re:Linus Torvalds on security by mechanical_fish on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @03:17PM (#247863)
Hooray for context!