News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by benmmurphy on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @04:16PM (#24781053)
It wouldn’t prove they were authentic. It would just prove they were sent through gmail’s servers. If you trusted gmail then it would prove the username, time and content was legitimate.

All it looks like to me is some Russian username. I don’t see how it ties to a real person. I haven’t read the article so maybe the post explains that bit.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by onionisafruit on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @08:19PM (#24783345)
It could prove it was sent through gmails servers on April 17, 2015. There aren’t many people who would know the importance of the meeting five years ago. It would narrow the list of possible senders.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by takeda on Thursday October 15, 2020 @07:56PM (#24795829)
That information would still be meaningless unless we could prove that this e-mail is authentic. `[email protected]` - why would an Ukrainian citizen have "ukraine" in their e-mail address?

There are so many other red flags (in addition whether this e-mail was really send, and the account belongs to that person) for example if Hunter responded to it (if they had his laptop surely they could get that from outbox? Why somebody who cares enough about their laptop to get it to repair (if you have plenty of money, more likely you'll get a new one) not care about getting it back?

This would prove that gmail indeed sent the e-mail, but it wouldn't prove that the e-mail wasn't created few minutes earlier.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by donmcronald on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @06:04PM (#24782209)
It would be immediately obvious if they were a poor quality fake though. Like if someone typed it up in Word and exported it to PDF they wouldn’t be able to produce the DKIM signature.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by cm2187 on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @10:38PM (#24784286)
I think DKIM also signs the sender of the email. Does gmail enforces that only the owner of the mailbox can be the sender?