News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Books on meta-learning by aspirant on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @01:54PM (#247768)
I've never heard of meta-learning, but about a year ago I stumbled onto a branch of philosophy called epistemology or the Theory of Knowledge. My studies there have been absolutely exhilarating and disturbing.

Next time you see someone at the coffee machine, ask them them what is meant by knowledge, reason, belief, truth, evidence, opinion, conviction, and hypocrisy.

The incoherent jumble you'll get back is indicative of the broken and sloppy process of the attempt to process data into knowledge (learning).

Re:Ask HN: Books on meta-learning by aspirant on Friday October 03, 2008 @11:32AM (#322739)
I later found some material that comprehends both our thoughts.

""Systemic learning theory suggests that it is valuable to distinguish levels of learning.

It is clear that most learning that goes on within and outside learning institutions makes no difference at all to individuals’ or society’s overall paradigm. This is because it is first order learning or basic learning. Bateson distinguished three orders of learning and change, corresponding with increases in learning capacity.

Learning I - basic learning learning, thinking, knowing

Learning II - meta-learning learning about learning, thinking about thinking, knowing about knowing

Learning III: epistemic learning learning about learning about learning, thinking about thinking about thinking, knowing about knowing about knowing

Seeing as how no one may ever read this post, I'm not going to expound any more, but again, I have found studying epistemology to be exhilarating.

Re:Ask HN: Books on meta-learning by aaronblohowiak on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @06:00PM (#248007)
It is easy to describe those terms through their role in interpersonal interaction and culture, but to either 1) make any claim about the working of the mind or 2) try to bridge the gap between symbol and signified is asking for heartache and endless rhetorical squabbling.
Re:Ask HN: Books on meta-learning by aspirant on Thursday July 17, 2008 @06:41PM (#249193)
Studying a theory of knowledge for the past year hasn't left me with a bunch of definitions, but with models for the acquisition of knowledge that have proven very useful.

I'm sure someone probably told Newton that all that math stuff looked like more trouble than it was worth.

Re:Ask HN: Books on meta-learning by aaronblohowiak on Thursday July 17, 2008 @11:01PM (#249406)
Oh, surely. I myself have a great deal of interest in knowledge and skill acquisition (in particular, the differences between first and successive language acquisition, but i digress.) Studying processes and patterns in learning can be a fascinating and deeply enriching experience. My comment was intended to warn against delving into endless debate over terms. I see how my (1) was worded incorrectly, instead it should have said something like "to argue about the emergence of consciousness from the material world and its role on the nature of subjective experience and truth", which i do believe is not a fruitful discussion. If anyone has a particularly convincing or useful discourse about the previous I am open to change, but as it stands all I've read on the matter has been speculation and/or justification for some moral or social agenda.
Re:Ask HN: Books on meta-learning by khafra on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @03:47PM (#247896)
Unless you just happen to work with, say, Eliezer Yudkowsky; or zombie Phillip K. Dick.
Re:Ask HN: Books on meta-learning by jobeirne on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @06:18PM (#248022)
Philip K. Dick would make an excellent zombie.