The big difference is seamless integration with other Apple products. This is why they’ll take market share, it will just work with your iPhone better than the echo does.
A limiting factor is Siri. It took them 8 years to allow asking to play a particular song on Spotify.
Usually the first thing I say to Siri is 'Hey Google' so it goes to Google Assistant.
I'm not really sure what "seamless integration" is left. I (and my friends that have similar devices) use smart speakers for power control, getting the weather, playing music, and setting timers/alarms. It doesn't take an sole-source ecosystem to make that work well.
I agree with this "innovation is dead" sentiment. Apple used to be pioneers and futurists. Now they focus on retaining their well-defined market. This almost makes sense, except they have such a tremendous amount of cash they can afford to take risks.
This is a full 5 years after the Amazon Echo was introduced.
This just adds to my creeping feeling that innovation is dead at Apple.