News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Sex Is Real by verytrivial on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @03:12PM (#24769085)
Made sense to me. It's basically saying a context-sensitive definition of "sex" does a disservice to either science or to society. There are people arguing literally that human sex is "assigned" at birth instead of just observed. This is all part of the gender identity and/or expression holy war currently being waged in the West and likely flamed by bad actors on social media, Twitter in particular.
Re:Sex Is Real by reanimus on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @03:10PM (#24769063)
"Biological sex is important to consider in biology but that doesn't mean it's important elsewhere."
Re:Sex Is Real by throw_m239339 on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @03:15PM (#24769122)
> "Biological sex is important to consider in biology but that doesn't mean it's important elsewhere."

AKA "you might ignore biology when it comes to make political decisions so that me and other biologists are not labelled bigots"? The conclusion of that article is a cop-out.

Re:Sex Is Real by Spivak on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @03:40PM (#24769437)
I'm not sure how you took that from the paragraph. What they're saying is that biological sex is a real, valid concept to biologists. No biologist is going to be called a bigot for saying that biological sex is a thing. (However, in non-academic contexts this statement is used by bigots as a dog-whistle. It's pretty darn obvious when this happens though.)
Re:Sex Is Real by throw_m239339 on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @04:18AM (#24774367)
> No biologist is going to be called a bigot for saying that biological sex is a thing

The fact that this article was flagged proves you wrong.

> However, in non-academic contexts this statement is used by bigots as a dog-whistle.

A dogwhistle for what exactly? please explain.

Re:Sex Is Real by Aardwolf on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @03:09PM (#24769048)
For one, English seems to suffer from having the same word mean two different things (gender, and an activity), that makes it already harder to parse.
Re:Sex Is Real by slowmovintarget on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @04:56PM (#24770200)
No the difficulty, in English, is that gender originally meant one's biological sex. There has been a concerted effort to assert that perceived gender and gender are the same. The confusion is deliberate.

From Webster's Dictionary (1828):

> 1. Properly, kind; sort.

> 2. A sex, male or female. Hence,

> 3. In grammar, a difference in words to express distinction of sex; usually a difference of termination in nouns, adjectives and participles, to express the distinction of male and female. But although this was the original design of different terminations, yet in the progress of language, other words having no relation to one sex or the other, came to have genders assigned them by custom. Words expressing males are said to be of the masculine gender; those expressing females, of the feminine gender; and in some languages, words expressing things having no sex, are of the neuter or neither gender

Nowadays, the political effort is to tie people in mental knots over how a person feels about their gender, how a person presents themselves, and how a person prefers to be addressed.

Re:Sex Is Real by happytoexplain on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @03:18PM (#24769165)
It sounds like it's making a case that people pretend the concept of biological sex doesn't exist as some kind of defense for social concepts of sex, but that seems like a straw man. I've rarely (never?) heard anybody insist that there are not multiple contexts for the concept of sex/gender.
Re:Sex Is Real by cik2e on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @04:07PM (#24769744)
I encourage you to google “biological sex isn’t real” and acquaint yourself with this line of thinking.

Radical gender theory does in fact make the bold claim that biological sex isn’t real. That’s right, sex, not gender. The postmodernist underpinnings used to support these types of ideas are rooted in concepts like “objective truth does not exist” and “everything is a social construct”.

Re:Sex Is Real by Volundr on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @05:20PM (#24770432)
I took your challenge, and, well I couldn't find it. I did find articles like this one https://www.forbes.com/sites/kimelsesser/2020/06/15/the-myth.... If you read only the headline you might think it's making the argument your implying, but if you actually bother to read it you'll find it doesn't.

From the article:

"The biology of sex is real, but it’s extremely complicated, and there is sometimes no easy way to draw a line between the biologically male and female."

Having now read the top 5 articles for that search term, I still haven't found one that makes the claim your suggesting.

I'm sure if I dig hard enough I could find that someone has said it non-ironically, but if I dig hard enough I can find someone saying the moon landing didn't happen or talking about lizard people non-ironically. That doesn't make it a mainstream movement.

Re:Sex Is Real by akvadrako on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @05:37PM (#24770604)
The idea that sex is non-binary and socially constructed is certainly around. The first time I heard it was about a year ago on an podcast interview from Sam Harris with an expert in the field of gender studies or something, saying we should consider that gay men might actually be women.

One recent event that brings it to light is JK Rowling said something along those lines, basically that women menstrate¹, and that caused a lot of controversy. I'm sure you'll be able to find plenty of articles against her for saying that.

[1] https://twitter.com/jk_rowling/status/1269382518362509313

Re:Sex Is Real by Volundr on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @09:27PM (#24772252)
Sure. But they aren't saying biological sex doesn't exist. They are saying there is sex and gender and that these two things can be different. Specifically sex is biological, while gender is a social and physiological construct. What is explicitly NOT being said is that biological sex is non-existent. And they are saying that a person's gender may be female while their biological sex can be male (or ambiguous), and that these people should still be considered women. That's very different from saying biological sex doesn't exist.
Re:Sex Is Real by akvadrako on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @02:38AM (#24773772)
That is comprehensible except it isn't related to what I said. This thread isn't about gender - it's about sex.

It's good you haven't understood people saying sex isn't biological, because it's not a defensible position. Hopefully their voices don't become more prominent.

Re:Sex Is Real by DanBC on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @04:32AM (#24774442)
> basically that women menstrate¹

Lots of women don't menstruate. Children, older women, women who've had hysterectomies, some women with intersex conditions, and transwomen.

Some men do menstruate. Transmen, and some people with intersex conditions.

This argument is not saying that "sex isn't real". It's saying that using terms that define sex are not good enough for some topics.

Re:Sex Is Real by Kednicma on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @01:48AM (#24773510)
Biological sex has more than two configurations of sex chromosomes possible, in humans. This isn't rocket science, although it is biology.

Also, on your other points: Objective truths can exist, but not all measurements are objective. Not everything is a social construct, but the things that humans believe without empirical evidence are all social constructs.

Postmodernism isn't hard. Y'all're just extremely convinced that reality is locally real, just because you can sense it so vividly, and you're blind to your biases as a result.

Re:Sex Is Real by DanBC on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @04:27AM (#24774412)
> Radical gender theory does in fact make the bold claim that biological sex isn’t real.

No.

Transphobes[1] will say that sex is obvious and the binary is clear.

The argument being made against transphobes is that definitions for "female" (or "male") can't exclude trans-people while including everyone else traditionally thought of as female (or male). That's something that transphobes claims is easy, and they're wrong.

[1] Many transphobes say this. It doesn't mean that anyone who says this is transphobic.

Re:Sex Is Real by Spivak on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @03:26PM (#24769254)
Yeah, when you get organic terminology like this it always kinda gets weird. The words sex and gender have been used to describe people's "social sex"/"gender identity"/"gender presentation" and their biological sex depending on the context.

Like a trans woman's drivers license and birth certificate will say female so it's hard to cleanly say that sex === biological sex.