Re:HTTPSNow
by jerf on Friday April 22, 2011 @11:33PM
(#2476194)
"When you really think about it, self-signed certificates are kind of misleading."
Given the ease of obtaining a root certificate, I'd say nowadays they're a great deal less deceptive than some CA-signed certificates. Visiting a site that has a self-signed cert doesn't prove your connection is safe. Visiting a site that has a CA-signed cert doesn't prove your connection is safe. What's the point of this exercise again?
I'm not sure at all what your second paragraph gives us. We don't need a fourth party to mediate the certification the third party gives us. The whole process of cert signing is a certification from a third party. That part actually works; the problem is that browsers accept signatures from organizations they should not, and the meta-problem is that there really isn't a solution to that problem. (What cert organization is secure against their local law enforcement?)
Given the ease of obtaining a root certificate, I'd say nowadays they're a great deal less deceptive than some CA-signed certificates. Visiting a site that has a self-signed cert doesn't prove your connection is safe. Visiting a site that has a CA-signed cert doesn't prove your connection is safe. What's the point of this exercise again?
I'm not sure at all what your second paragraph gives us. We don't need a fourth party to mediate the certification the third party gives us. The whole process of cert signing is a certification from a third party. That part actually works; the problem is that browsers accept signatures from organizations they should not, and the meta-problem is that there really isn't a solution to that problem. (What cert organization is secure against their local law enforcement?)