News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reform the PhD system or close it down by codedivine on Friday April 22, 2011 @03:01PM (#2475044)
I agree that disseminating your results is important. However, in computer science at least, "publication" in academic community is applied very narrowly. I think incentive needs to be given for "dissemination of useful knowledge and artifacts" rather than only "publications".

You open-sourced your source code? Sorry, source code is not a publication. You improved your source code so that it is less buggy and acutally usable by industry? Sorry not a publication. You want to travel to PyCon to actually talk about your work to a wider audience? Sorry no travel funding available for such "non-academic" conferences. You want to cite an open-source work that did innovative work but not in academic setting? Sorry that is not a good enough citation ("who is this _why anyway?"), please include more citations of "academic" papers.

Funding incentive is only there for publishing your results but less incentive is there for building of useful working systems.

Re:Reform the PhD system or close it down by TheEzEzz on Friday April 22, 2011 @03:07PM (#2475069)
I would love to see the day where having a successful library on github being used by other researchers would be valued as much as publishing a paper or two.