News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It Takes a School, Not Missiles by edw519 on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @08:01AM (#247502)
I agree with you, davidw.

Except we're beginning to have a new problem here at hn.

The only thing worse than threads about politics, religion, drugs, or popular culture are the comments about how they're not "hacker news".

We're starting to sound like a committee that gets together and spends most of our time writing the agenda.

Re:It Takes a School, Not Missiles by davidw on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @08:34AM (#247518)
Saying "these discussions are even worse than the ones they seek to avoid" is an easy out though, unless there's some other way to express our dissatisfaction with said politics articles (down arrow, or whatever else). Furthermore, they serve to pass on information to new members of the community.
Re:It Takes a School, Not Missiles by edw519 on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @09:43AM (#247555)
Fair enough.
Re:It Takes a School, Not Missiles by DanielBMarkham on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @08:27AM (#247512)
It's much more fun to square off right vs. left and have at it.

But it's not hn.

Davidw is right, in my opinion.

Perhaps the reason we keep having this discussion is that the board continues to serve up material that we find innappropriate? That people vote based on emotion, not on whether it is good material for hackers, and political stuff has the most emotion-laden content of all?

This is a nice seque into our other favorite topic: how rating systems are broken. I'm afraid these two are highly connected.

Re:It Takes a School, Not Missiles by edw519 on Wednesday July 16, 2008 @09:44AM (#247556)
people vote based on emotion

Yes! Even more so with their purchasing dollars. A nonintuitive but incredibly important lesson for any budding entrepreneur.