Still, I’d say the best researchers/professors that I’ve met combined a deep understanding of the techniques in their own line of research with a broad understanding of their field and adjacent fields. Personally, I’d fear that removing technical proficiency as a requirement for a PhD would eliminate an essential bullshit detector that filters out certain people; people who do a great job speaking in broad generality but are incapable of formulating a path to accomplish these grand aims.
(As a quick anecdote, I once saw a research presentation from a grad student who made broad claims about his project’s direct role in curing many forms of cancer. As he progressed, we learned he was only exploring strategies to synthesize a potential ligand that some other researchers would consider using in imaging a specific cancer within rat models. To this end he showed very little progress, but continued to speak at great lengths about the imminent eradication of cancer as he concluded his talked.)
I believe you have some misgivings about what a PhD is.
The mandate of the PhD is to create new knowledge (independent research) in a particular, self-chosen area. That's difficult to do when you're focusing on breadth rather than depth. Once you've proven that you can go deep, by all means, get a faculty position and start your own (broad) research program, or get a job in industry and go broad. The PhD is about proving that you can go deep, which usually also involves some breadth.