> Not to mention that the huge benefit of batteries is nearly instant (single-digit millisecond!) reaction time, allowing power demand fluctuations to be efficiently smoothed out. Hydrogen can't do that, even with fuel cells.
And hydrogen doesn't need to do that. An optimized system would include batteries to smooth over such rapid changes in the system. This is another species of the "hydrogen can't do everything, therefore it isn't useful for anything" fallacy.
What's better for seasonal storage?
b) Anything. Anything is better for seasonal storage. Methane, pumped hydro, molten salt, flow batteries, etc... all of those are existing, or viable right now, not in some fantasy future where we all have fusion-powered flying cars.
c) The free market tends to take care of such things. Power is a fungible commodity. If electricity is seasonally cheaper, it'll just be used by industry for power-hungry processes such as smelting aluminium or titanium. You can then store those end products by simply putting them in a pile.
In a renewable-energy future, it would make sense to use electricity when it is cheap to make hydrocarbons that require its physical or chemical properties, e.g.: to make industrial chemicals, pharmaceuticals, polymers, etc...
We already know how to store hydrocarbons. You pour them into a simple metal tank. Easy.
We don't know how to store hydrogen. Still. After decades or research.
You keep mentioning hydrogen as somehow superior for long term energy storage when the opposite is true.
> Anything. Anything is better for seasonal storage.
Let's go through that list.
Methane: you make that from hydrogen and CO2. Where is the CO2 coming from? The cost of capturing the CO2 will likely overshadow any savings in cavern space.
Flow batteries: obviously not economical. They might be good for a week or so of storage. For half a year? No.
Pumped hydro: the water volumes involved are too large (see other response.)
Molten salt: this will be stored in tanks above ground, and these will be more expensive per unit energy stored than underground hydrogen caverns. Getting the heat out of the salt is also problematic. Heat exchangers (and heat rejection on the other side of steam turbines) are not that cheap.
I don't think any of the alternatives you have proposed actually are superior to hydrogen.
> We don't know how to store hydrogen. Still. After decades or research.
Yes we do. In underground caverns. This is a known technology; it's already been done.
As for pumped hydro. Let's suppose we want to store 10% of the annual US power demand in a pumped hydro reservoir with a 200m head. The volume required is about 2000 cubic kilometers, about four years of the total flow of the Mississippi River. I don't think this is terribly practical.
Thermal storage may be competitive for efficiency, but the capital cost is likely to be higher, as you need more heat exchangers and cooling systems. Combustion turbines are cheap, especially simple cycle.
But in any case, the energy density argument I made is independent of just where the compressed gases are being stored.
Hydrogen is the worst at everything, if compared to all available alternatives, not batteries only. Other technologies outperform it very substantially in almost every metric, often simultaneously.
Hydrogen is energy inefficient to produce, space inefficient to store, dangerously explosive, reactive with common engineering metals, and unproven.
The one thing hydrogen is optimal for is mass efficiency, but methane is almost as good and far easier and safer to store than hydrogen, and has a much higher energy density by volume, which matters more than you'd think, even for planes and rockets. The new super-heavy rocket designed by Space X uses methane, and the current ones use kerosene.
For grid storage, the sole advantage of Hydrogen -- its low density -- is utterly pointless. Nobody cares how heavy building-sized storage is. Efficiency matters, and the electricity-to-hydrogen-to-electricity round trip efficiency is woeful. There's no clear way to make this anywhere near as efficient as batteries either.
Not to mention that the huge benefit of batteries is nearly instant (single-digit millisecond!) reaction time, allowing power demand fluctuations to be efficiently smoothed out. Hydrogen can't do that, even with fuel cells.
Lastly, we make hydrogen for ammonia to use as fertiliser. This doesn't in any way mean that it this is efficient or worthwhile for power storage.