Re:Making the Monty Hall problem weirder but obvious
by basch on Thursday October 08, 2020 @01:44PM
(#24721654)
There are only three situations. Initial pick in parentheses.
(C)GG - switch and lose
(G)CG - switch and win
(G)GC - switch and win
Re:Making the Monty Hall problem weirder but obvious
by furyofantares on Thursday October 08, 2020 @04:14PM
(#24723393)
By the time you have the decision, yeah, that's true.
There are other situations where the game is over before you get a decision.
Both GCG and GGC are eliminated half the time before you get to make a decision. But CGG is never eliminated before you get to make a decision.
Once you're making a decision and the game isn't already over, you can use this information -- that the game didn't end -- to assign a 50% chance of being in CGG, and 25% of each of the other two.
Alright just working through your logic here. Let's say I pick the first door always. I'll write out all the possible configurationss with both possibilities for Monty.
CGG > Monty reveals mid (Goat)
CGG > Monty reveals right (Goat)
----
GCG > Monty reveals mid (Car)
GCG > Monty reveals right (Goat)
---
GGC > Monty reveals mid (Goat)
GGC > Monty reveals right (Car)
So there's 4 worlds where Monty reveals a goat. In two of them, I picked a car initially. In the other two, I get a car by switching.
My prior post is mistaken -- thank you!