News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by elisbce on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @10:24PM (#24715000)
Any affirmative action is by definition discriminating on the basis of race. If you want the best candidate for the job, you don't look at race, you look at their abilities to do the job. Period. Any bias towards hiring one race implies bias against hiring from other races. Why is it okay to have almost no Asian players in the NBA while a small percentage of black people in tech is a big fuss? It is all hypocrisy.
Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by john_moscow on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @10:55PM (#24715190)
The elephant in the room is that due to rather dark times in the U.S. history, there are cultural differences between an average Black and an average White family. It doesn't mean that every family of a certain race will fit the stereotype, but if you look at numbers, they do check out. This isn't fair, this isn't nice, but it's a very important piece of the puzzle and you cannot solve the problem without admitting it.

Many of these cultural differences are crucial to getting high-paid positions. Like nagging on your kids to study. Like making sure their role models are scientists and inventors, and not gang leaders. Like stressing out delayed gratification and showing how planning and persistence pays off in long term.

If you look very carefully at company founders and people on high-paying jobs, almost every one of them will be from a family with these long-term values. Many Blacks have adopted these values and are successful. Nobody is telling them to go to a different drinking fountain, it's not 1930s anymore. So if you want to fix the problem for good, you need to advertise these values more, teach them at school, and give good examples. Maybe, remove roadblocks like providing free textbooks programming lessons for those in need. Unfortunately, this takes time, effort and only pays off for the next generation. So the racial equality movement has been hijacked by politicians that offer a short-term solution: divide people by the most visible factor, such as skin color, then take from the overrepresented and give to the underrepresented.

Except in the long term, it makes the society more divisive. If you hire a weaker candidate based on quotas, other employees will see the weakness and won't respect them. The employee will perceive this as racism and get offensive. If you try to further address it by promotion quotas, you start getting cliques where Blacks always side with other Blacks, and Whites always side with Whites. You've just created racism out of nowhere.

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by cjohnson318 on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @11:13PM (#24715308)
> So the racial equality movement has been hijacked by politicians that offer a short-term solution: divide people by the most visible factor, such as skin color, then take from the overrepresented and give to the underrepresented.

I think this is totally backwards. If anything, the U.S. government takes from the underrepresented and gives to the overrepresented. This is achieved through gerrymandering districts to dilute minority votes, limiting voting sites, and asking "concerned citizens" to "monitor" voting locations. Our social welfare programs pale in comparison to the subsidies and tax cuts given to big businesses, and other overrepresented groups.

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by john_moscow on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @11:17PM (#24715331)
I'm not talking about the federal government. I meant affirmative action programs on institution level. I guess, "activists" would be a better word than "politicians".
Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by cjohnson318 on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @11:28PM (#24715406)
So are you talking about "activists" in HR, or management? I don't know what you're talking about with respect to taking from the "overrepresented" and giving to the "underrepresented". Under- and overrepresentation is unusual wording for salaried employees in an institution.
Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by marcusverus on Thursday October 08, 2020 @08:31AM (#24718510)
>Our social welfare programs pale in comparison to the subsidies and tax cuts given to big businesses, and other overrepresented groups.

Tax cuts aren't spending and untaxed externalities aren't subsidies. Unfortunately, for whatever reason, the use of intentionally misleading language isn't as taboo as lying, so we'll keep seeing this old canard for the foreseeable future.

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by cjohnson318 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @11:31AM (#24720065)
I am not trying to mislead anyone, this is my reasoning for using the language that I did. A subsidy is a sum of money given by the government to a corporation, so it is analogous to government spending on social welfare programs. A tax cut reduces the government's income, which on a balance sheet, has the same effect as government spending. Sure, a tax cutting policy is not the same as a spending policy, but their net effect on cash flow are both negative.
Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by diffrinse on Thursday October 08, 2020 @12:39PM (#24720851)
> The elephant in the room is that due to rather dark times in the U.S. history, there are cultural differences between an average Black and an average White family. It doesn't mean that every family of a certain race will fit the stereotype, but if you look at numbers, they do check out. This isn't fair, this isn't nice, but it's a very important piece of the puzzle and you cannot solve the problem without admitting it.

I am loving this utter shit assumption that is clearly being taken as gospel given the upvotes.

Do you actually believe the AVERAGE Black person you describe is not only engaging in tech with gusto but also good enough to get an interview for a senior staff position at Microsoft?

Ah, but the assumption is not only that this will be the case, but that Microsoft will also just blindly hire said person to "satisfy quotas"... WHEN HAS THAT EVER HAPPENED!?!?

You don't even have a personal anecdote of seeing this happen, and I doubt few of the people upvoting this dribble actually have, and more than likely not to any significant degree in the aggregate either.

Like, holy shit, if your description of an average Black is true, that entire curve on the bell don't even COME CLOSE to participating in tech AT ALL. Good job on the completely un-contextual resort to "statistical reasoning" to dunk on Black people.

Not to mention you show your colors when you fail to account for the children of African immigrants rather than the descendants of slaves in the US. But no, let's believe there's a line of unwashed Black masses, brutish and poorly educated, standing in an employment line that wraps around the Redmond campus waiting to get that hand-out job.

Fuckin hell, what is really happening in the tech industry is that a number of you aren't hiring perfectly qualified people because their afro or some such made you uncomfortable so they were told they weren't hired for "culture fit".

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by john_moscow on Thursday October 08, 2020 @01:14PM (#24721331)
I am not trying do dunk anyone. I am merely trying to suggest a solution that will be less divisive, because the current one is creating tension rather than easing it.

Also unfortunately, our brains are not naturally good with statistics, so many things may seem counter-intuitive until you look into details. Here's some napkin math model (numbers are arbitrary). Assume that we can assign an abstract "techiness score" to every person that will correlate with their chances of being hired.

Assume we have 10 people of population A and 10 people of population B. For population A it's:

* 1 person with score 0

* 7 people with score 5

* 1 person with score 9

* 1 person with score 10

For population B it's:

* 1 person with score 0

* 1 person with score 1

* 7 people with score 5

* 1 person with score 10

The difference it not that large, but if you simply hire everyone with score 8 and up, you get 2 people from population A and 1 person from population B. If you talk to these 3 people, you will see that there is no difference between them in terms of score and can easily conclude that the 2x difference is due to treating people based on their population.

If you introduce a hiring quota, you are forced to hire 1 person with score 5 from population B, and that's where the problem starts because they will be perceived weak and will trigger divisive behavior I mentioned.

As I said several times, I'm not concluding that ALL or MOST Blacks are bad or anything. I'm saying that there are statistical differences that are hard to measure and that can explain workforce underrepresentation. Other metrics you may want to look at is:

* Black-on-white crime vs. white-on-black crime.

* Families with both parents.

* Change in student loan principal after 5 years. This shows whether a certain population is choosing degrees that pay off.

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by mav3rick on Thursday October 08, 2020 @10:35PM (#24726164)
Any thing that goes against the majority "creates tension". Doesn't mean we abolish it.
Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by proc0 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @03:48AM (#24716876)
"Many of these cultural differences are crucial to getting high-paid positions. Like nagging on your kids to study. Like making sure their role models are scientists and inventors, and not gang leaders. Like stressing out delayed gratification and showing how planning and persistence pays off in long term."

Haven't you heard these are racist values? Seriously, many of these values are frowned upon, and deemed "white", even though it's what has worked for so long across the world.

I'm afraid this equity, as best-intention as it might be, will make the problem worse by creating a dependency that will further define the culture as needing this form of victimhood status.

Imagine the year 2143, people will have digital assistants, flying cars and also diversity and inclusion training will tell you how oppressed some people still are. It's easier to blame history than to admit you are stupid and need to make better decisions in life.

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by zaroth on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @10:36PM (#24715064)
There’s no getting around the fact. To the point where California is currently debating whether to remove the following phrase from their State Constitution;

The State shall not discriminate against, or grant preferential treatment to, any individual or group on the basis of race, sex, color, ethnicity, or national origin in the operation of public employment, public education, or public contracting.

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by meroes on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @10:28PM (#24715025)
And is that mutually exclusive to creating more opportunities for minorities to apply?

And what if the current practices sans AA are already discriminatory (e.g. try having certain natural hairstyles at your interview that don't fit the status quo)...

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by throwawaysea on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @10:42PM (#24715103)
Setting quotas/goals doesn’t seem like the right approach though. We can try to correct for the biases you name without setting numerical targets. The thing is, there isn’t any correct number to aim for. For instance, some cultures emphasize STEM education/careers and it isn’t surprising or incorrect to see them represented in tech at numbers higher than their makeup of the general population. Setting targets like proportional demographic representation for blacks or any other racial group ultimately amounts to racist discrimination against those other races.
Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by goldenManatee on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @10:49PM (#24715161)
What are 2 or 3 “right approaches” for improving diversity in tech? Unless, the view is that practices until now have been right?

Cultural support for STEM comes through parents who themselves are capable of sitting at the dinner table to help kids with their math and science homework. Parents who encourage careers such as mechanical engineering, not just being a car mechanic because that feels most familiar to people they already know.

So what are some “right approaches” for achieving more diverse workforces?

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by Dwolb on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @10:54PM (#24715184)
Whether someone can do a job is a mix of experience and potential (y-intercept and slope). It’s difficult for interviewers to assess potential so many rely on experience as the key indicator.

It’s difficult for candidates from disadvantaged to show the same level of experience as candidates from non-disadvantaged backgrounds. Therefore candidates from disadvantaged backgrounds are systematically segmented out from the hiring pool.

Well-run diversity programs aim to better assess the potential of disadvantaged candidates and there are a variety of indicators for success.

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by proc0 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @03:29AM (#24716778)
It's worse than hypocrisy, it's accomplishing the opposite of what it's supposed to do. It's only a matter of time until there is an obvious gap in skill, which will only hurt the reputation of that group and then the situation could backfire when conflict starts arising among people with different skillset.
Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by nickpeterson on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @10:37PM (#24715080)
Let’s use that NBA example, is the lack of Asian NBA players a problem? If it is, how would you go about fixing it?
Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by cjohnson318 on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @10:43PM (#24715119)
Managers tend to take the three most highly qualified candidates and then, "all things being equal", hire the one most similar to them. It doesn't take a big brain to figure out how that has played out historically.
Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by ausbah on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @10:35PM (#24715061)
how about racial biases in hiring? no hiring is completely meritocratic, even in tech
Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by geitir on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @11:13PM (#24715306)
This post is no longer showing up for me on the front page or even the second page. Can anyone else verify?
Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by john_moscow on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @11:23PM (#24715364)
Verified.

The thing is, Affirmative Action is one of those topics where having a "wrong" opinion is seen as treason by these in power. And far too many people here had the "wrong" opinion. The good news is, the tide is turning.

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by paxys on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @10:46PM (#24715140)
Yes it is definitely discrimination, but not all such discrimination is illegal or morally wrong.
Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by xvector on Thursday October 08, 2020 @12:44AM (#24715906)
> but not all such discrimination is illegal or morally wrong.

Tell that to the Asian kid that just learnt that he now has to slave away at his studies because of his skin color.

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by Hnrobert42 on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @10:58PM (#24715214)
MS could increase their diversity by broadening where they advertise job listings, developing mentorship programs at schools with more diverse populations, or even simply changing the language used in job postings. Building a diverse work force need not (indeed should not) be as simplistic as hiring inferior candidates because they meet some quota.

Building a diverse workforce should be about making sure you get the very best people in the job. If the composition of their leadership team is dramatically skewed from the demographics of the general population, how can they argue that they scoured the country and found the very best?

The reason the NBA is different is because sports are based on physical abilities. Race, by definition, is a difference in physical traits. It is therefore unsurprising that race has a bearing on diversity in sports. Race has not been shown to have any bearing on one’s ability to do the work MS needs.

Why am I even explaining this to you? Can you seriously not understand the difference. FFS.

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by john_moscow on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @11:07PM (#24715267)
Race is very strongly correlated with culture. And many cultural traits are crucial to doing work that companies need. It's just very hard to measure one's culture and it's very easy to measure their skin color.

I don't think forcing companies to be diverse per skin color is a good idea. A much better way could be finding aspiring people from underrepresented populations and removing roadblocks on the way of specific people.

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by cjohnson318 on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @11:18PM (#24715339)
> I don't think forcing companies to be diverse per skin color is a good idea.

Microsoft is not being forced hire more diverse leadership; this Microsoft's own internal initiative.

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by john_moscow on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @11:25PM (#24715377)
Someone at the board suggested it, and if anyone else opposed it, they would lose their seat as a racist.

That is effectively being forced.

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by cjohnson318 on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @11:37PM (#24715467)
I think the list of board members of major companies that have lost their seat due to real or perceived racism is extremely short, unless you have a long list of them lying about.

I seriously doubt a whole board was strong-armed by a single person, and if it was a plurality of board members that suggested this, then that's how boards are intended to work.

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by john_moscow on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @11:43PM (#24715506)
I think, after the James D'Amore case, anyone with 10% of the wits needed to get to FAANG board learned to shut up and nod.

You don't get that high up without playing the political game, and the rules of the game at this point are very clear.

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by cjohnson318 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @12:54AM (#24715965)
So you do not have a long list of board members that have lost their seat due to real or perceived racism.

What are these rules of this game, explicitly? And who enforces them?

Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by mav3rick on Thursday October 08, 2020 @10:33PM (#24726155)
Where's the list ? All your points are "assumptions". D'Amore made dubious claims at best and antagonized at least half the company.
Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by Hnrobert42 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @07:48PM (#24725217)
That sounds like speculation not fact. In such a emotionally charge discussion, we are better served by facts.
Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by mav3rick on Thursday October 08, 2020 @10:32PM (#24726149)
Let me guess - you must be white ?
Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by Hnrobert42 on Monday October 12, 2020 @10:31PM (#24761675)
I support the rest of your comments in this thread, but this comment seems irrelevant at best. Our position is better served by attacking the argument, not the person.
Re:Microsoft probed by US government over aim to double blac... by Hnrobert42 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @07:46PM (#24725194)
Who said anything about forcing?