As I said, the outcome per game will be different (since you suddenly have an additional opportunity to lose), but the math around whether or not to switch when shown a goat remains unchanged.
To put it another way, if Monty is choosing randomly, half the time where you would win by switching, instead the game just ends/isn't counted, but the same is not true of the case where you win by not switching. From a bayesian point of view, Monty randomly revealing a goat should increase your belief that you picked the car the first time.
That said, switching is not worse than not switching unless Monty is biased towards revealing the car instead.
1) I roll a 3-sided die (or a 6 sided, wrapping) and keep it covered.
2) You pick a number, 1-3
3) I flip a coin. If it's heads, I pick the lower available number; if it's tails I pick the higher.
4) I peak at the die. If it's my number, we reveal and start over.
5) I (always, at this point) offer you a wager: if the die shows your number (so you would have lost if you switch), you pay me $7; if the die doesn't show your number, I pay you $5.
Assuming you believe the die and coin are fair, etc, would you agree to play that game 1000 times? In those games, is there a reason you would turn down the wager?Is it the same game if I flip the coin secretly, peek at the die, announce my number (picked algorithmically in the obvious way), and then pay out according to whether switching would win (as above)?
Because (assuming I've explained these games as I intend... it's getting late) I would play the former with you not the latter (but I would play the latter if we switched the payments around - I chose 5 and 7 because 7/12 is halfway between 1/2 and 2/3).
No, it does not.
>> if (montys_choice === car_door) { i -= 1; continue; }
This discards the game where Monty chose a car.
>> do { montys_choice = Math.floor(Math.random() * 3); } while (montys_choice === my_choice || montys_choice === car_door);
This makes Monty never choose a door with a car.
Neither one counts the game where Monty opened a door with a car as a win for either staying or switching.