If you heard that your neighbor Bob is a creepy pedo, then warning other people is frankly natural. If you dislike Bob and make up a rumor about him that should be illegal.
For powerful public persons the balance is different. The benefits of being able to freely discuss them starts outweighing the harm they suffer from false allegations.
That's my current thinking anyway.
No, there isn't, morally or legally.
If you make defamatory statements, it doesn't matter whether you made them up or simply heard someone else say them and are just passing them along. It's still defamatory, and that's how US law treats such statements (and how it has always treated defamatory statements).
Truth is the defense to a defamation lawsuit, not "a little bird told me."
TLDR: unless you actually know that Bob is a pedo because you witnessed his crimes or he has been convicted, don't defame Bob.
> You have no right to such a behavior in civil society.
That's the justification used in every society that oppressed.
"Civil" seems like the mantra used by one side to demand control and censorship today when in the past, it was the other side.