Here are a couple examples:
* http://www.bostonherald.com/news/regional/view.bg?articleid=...
* http://chronicle.com/article/Many-More-Students-Are/66223/
Thiel's program is more of a signal than anything. I dropped out of college five years ago, and people thought I was crazy. I had lunch a couple months ago with my high school classmates (from a regionally well-regarded prep school), and I'm pretty happy with how my career and prospects stack up.
But a problem has been identified here -- too many people are spending too much on money on phantom educational assets. Now the solution -- fewer people should go to college. (Especially expensive low to mid tier schools?) I guess what I was really asking above, is: so what should they do instead? And I'm guessing the answer ain't so pretty, something even more offensive to the idea of the American dream than the analogous housing case, of "sorry, just keep on renting."
And there's nothing wrong with renting, either. You buy housing as you need it, just like you buy food as you need it--I don't feel ripped off that I eat peaches but don't own an orchard.
The replacement of "educated" workers by technology suggests similar value problems. If someone is truly replaceable by automation, and can't find other work, were they ever properly educated in the first place? Or were they socialized to a particular work ethic, and trained to follow very complicated instructions? I would expect an educated person to use their analytic abilities and grasp of principles and ability to learn, to find how to use automation, somewhere, to do more work of better quality. If they can't do that, then I question just how well they were educated in the first place.
So the bubble might be reflected not in the price, but in the crummy product delivered at that price.
But I'd to read more about specific bad "educational investment" decisions, and what makes these decisions bad, as a way of prescribing better pathways for students sizing up their college or grad school options. Specifically, what are the bigger competing opportunities that should entice these "kids" away from educational debt and opportunity cost? Thiel's program can only be a very small part of the re-balancing act, I think.
Point me in the right direction if you've already read it...