News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by strogonoff on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:40AM (#24706369)
This is why meritocracy as it is now is flawed[0]. Smart people who work crazy hours, achieve a lot and obtain the appropriate status and wealth are also smart enough to know to invest tons and tons of money into their kids’ education and incentivise them to work as hard. Eventually it approaches a “pyramid scheme” where again only rich can win and everyone is unhappy.

[0] This is something Daniel Markovits talks about: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2019/09/meritoc...

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by andi999 on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @05:44AM (#24706633)
If you lool at it from a perspective of winning/loosing/fair/unfair you are probably right. If you look on the total effect of society then probably not. I mean to have competetive companies you need people who have worked(or played) their ass off and achieved skills and knowledge which only the mixture of privilege, work and skills can achieve. You actually want to give the smart kids extra tuition, because mostly these people will innovate later. (I dont mean to speak in absolutes here, but on average) Society is not only about distribution but to distribute something you have to create it first.

So I would say, yes it is a flaw of meritocracy, but meritocracy is not flawed.

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by strogonoff on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @07:33AM (#24707191)
That’s not what it’s about.

In a meritocracy, a person should become powerful/rich according to their merit—education, skill, diligence, etc. However, what then happens is elites start religiously investing all they can (and they can invest a lot) into ensuring their own offspring has even more of that merit than others.

As an exaggerated example, you can’t buy your kid a Pfeiffer turbopump to experiment with if you are choosing between bread and soap when you’re going to the store.

What we get as a result is the same ever-growing gap between the already-rich and the rest. Meritocracy turns into plutocracy as merit becomes more or less a proxy for wealth.

Breaking that trend would involve actions that go beyond meritocracy, and arguably are un-meritocratic: instead of just rewarding by merit, it’s about helping more people have that merit regardless of their or their parents’ wealth.

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by threatofrain on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @07:40AM (#24707221)
That’s not a confusion of merit and wealth. If I use wealth to teach you how to drive a truck or learn to program, that’s growing value inside a person. That person became stronger, and in the eyes of society, more meritorious for some tasks.

Merit is due to many things, and mentorship, experimentation, and preparation are all parts of it. Medical training is also very expensive and part of medical merit, but also clearly entangled in discussions of money, opportunity, and growing inequity.

If you have hidden biological talent but never trained as a doctor due to wealth, should we trust you now to perform medicine? Not before that expensive prep; it’s part of merit.

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by strogonoff on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @07:48AM (#24707259)
> Merit is due to many things, and mentorship, experimentation, and preparation are all parts of it. Medical training is also very expensive and part of medical merit, but also clearly entangled in discussions of money and opportunity.

Exactly, and if one has a lot of hard-earned wealth thanks to their own smarts and merit and drive to work hard they’ll of course happily spend it on all the right things to make sure their kids have even more of that than their parents. With private education and all that blocks opportunities for kids in lower income families and increase inequality; merit becomes a proxy for wealth and as meritocracy matures it becomes more and more a rule of the rich. (Being “a proxy for” is not the same as “being confused with”, it’s just that one would more or less follow the other.)

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by andi999 on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @11:24AM (#24709190)
Yes. And I believe this is sort of the best of all worlds. I find it better that like high paying jobs like a surgeon are given on merit (beeing a proxy for parents beeing rich, but still on merit) instead of given on e.g. power, like oh he is the son of ... he doesnt need to study to become a surgeon. Or whatever example you like.

The question is, how possible is it to level up. At least in Europe not so difficult, and in the US the Asian immigrants also show it is possible (if you think in terms of 2 generations).

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by andi999 on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @11:26AM (#24709206)
Also here: your example really shows the beneficial effects of this: the elite has to become extremely competent of the subject
Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by strogonoff on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @11:39AM (#24709337)
Money helps. It would be hard for me to become competent in something I wanted to educate my hypothetical kids about if I were struggling to make ends meet. On the other hand, if I were among the really rich, I would furnish my kids a well-equipped lab and ensure they get a chance to hang out around top experts in the field.
Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by andi999 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @03:23AM (#24716741)
I think nobody disagrees that money helps.
Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by ponker on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:59AM (#24706438)
Except not only the rich can win. My longtime barber is a Vietnamese guy who speaks very broken English. When I go and get a haircut his son was often in the store studying. My barber would tell him a math problem, like 257 times 191 or whatever, then the kid would produce the answer, then my barber would interrupt my haircut to whip out a calculator and check.

Kid got a full scholarship to Duke University. And I’ve seen this in other Asian immigrants as well, a cab driver in NYC whose daughter was at Cornell Medical School.

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by huffmsa on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @05:19AM (#24706516)
Barbering can be a surprising lucrative career. Especially men's barbering. Has a particularly high dollar/hour rate too.

Tooling is $1k for clippers and scissors and razors. Not sure about chairs, but probably another $1k.

Suppose you charge $20 a cut, typical cut takes ~15-20 minutes and you're open 360 days a year.

10 cuts/day => $72k/yr. 2-3 hours of work a day.

20 cuts/day => $144k/yr. 4-5 hours of work a day.

Find reasonable rent and you're netting a pretty good profit. And yes it's an easy space to enter, but generally, once men find "their barber", they're locked in for pretty much the rest of their life and become a regular customer every 2-3 weeks.

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by strogonoff on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @05:49AM (#24706666)
> once men find "their barber", they're locked in for pretty much the rest of their life and become a regular customer every 2-3 weeks.

I’m curious whether it’s really specific to male population, and if so why…

That aside, and I can’t believe that this is where the thread took us, I empathise so much with this. Even in countries where I can converse easily with anybody it’s a struggle for me to trust someone with my hair, despite me presumably not really caring about it. Now living in countries where I don’t speak local languages and locals predominantly don’t speak any of mine (or do so with much difficulty) I haven’t gone to a barber in years—I pretty much gave up and just live with terrible hair. I guess if I ever find “my barber” I may be willing to travel far to get my haircut.

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by tnli on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @05:46AM (#24706645)
Assuming you can keep your customer queue sufficient at all times, and that your clients can come when you are open.

Most likely this means a location that already has a high throughput of potential customers and that also most likely means a place that has high rents.

Sure, if you already have a place, like an extra room in your house, and you manage to establish yourself on the area. But even then you might find out that your first client wants to come in at 7 or 8 am, to get ready for whatever work thing they have that day, and the last client wants to come in at 8 pm, because they can’t earlier.

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by strogonoff on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @05:56AM (#24706704)
By the sound of it barbering resembles consulting a lot. Being in a lively area could help find some customers at first, but once you have established relationships with customers that value you specifically you can probably set up anywhere.

(And if someone wants to come in at strange hours for important work appearances, I’m sure they won’t mind being charged double the price either!)

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by ponker on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @01:38PM (#24710651)
LOL. 360 days a year tells me everything I need to know about your analysis.
Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by secondcoming on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @05:47AM (#24706652)
'Smart people tend to make good parents. This is unfair'

I'm not sure what actions you expect society to make to address this.

Should smart people deliberately not be good parents so that social justice can prevail in a world full of not-so-smart people?

Should not-so-smart people just not have children so society can be smarter as a whole?

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by strogonoff on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @07:11AM (#24707072)
> Should smart people deliberately not be good parents so that social justice can prevail in a world full of not-so-smart people?

> Should not-so-smart people just not have children so society can be smarter as a whole?

Perhaps smart people could spend some of their hard-earned money and prestige to ensure the whole society, not just their offspring, has more opportunities and access to good education? However, as you can see, that does not align with meritocratic ideals as they are currently being applied.

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by fierarul on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @05:53AM (#24706692)
Wow, that article: "meritocratic inequality". How would "meritocratic equality" look like!?

Interesting how the rich were blamed for being fat cats and not are blamed for overworking so much they win the race.

It seems some people are genuinely surprised there's more to money and status than just having the newest phone.

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by strogonoff on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @06:03AM (#24706738)
> How would "meritocratic equality" look like!?

I believe the article suggests things such as (but not only) changing education to be more accessible and inclusive, and making work done by employees without expensive education more valuable across industries.

> are blamed for overworking so much they win the race.

The point here is also that, while “winning the race” thanks to their hard work and abilities, under meritocracy as it is elites also produce more and more inequality in longer term, raising the bar and blocking middle and lower classes from opportunities.

(I would tentatively posit that the existence of a race to be won is the problem here.)

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by fierarul on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @08:48AM (#24707628)
Honestly it would be nice to stop beating around the bush and declare your end goal: communism. "From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs".

"Meritocratic equality" is an oxymoron. You can only attain it if what you are measuring applies to everybody, like, say, having a pulse.

The world is hyper-competitive. I don't believe the US will fare well with this excellent strategy.

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by strogonoff on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @11:29AM (#24709231)
> Honestly it would be nice to stop beating around the bush and declare your end goal: communism.

First, let’s agree on whether we both believe the problem with meritocracy, as it works currently, is real. If you don’t believe so, then there’s no sense in continuing.

Second, if the only solution you see is communism, don’t attribute the same outlook to me.

As far as I’m aware, if communist regimes so far are any indication, communism could only make the situation worse with blatant nepotism if nothing else.

What if, if a solution you can think of off the top of your head is horrible, all it means is that the problem is just not that easy to solve?

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by fierarul on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @01:33PM (#24710607)
If you want to promote the idea that there's more to life than work and that one could focus more on family, nature and the arts by all means.

But saying that capable people must bend the knee so somebody less capable also gets a turn at 1st prize makes we wonder want kind of morality asks that, accepts that and takes pride in finally winning that way.

Re:Middle school student achieved nuclear fusion in his fami... by strogonoff on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @03:34PM (#24711808)
No one is forced to bend the knee but recognising that meritocracy doesn't live up to its promise and is anti-egalitarian in long term may be welcome.