Re:Patent Lawyer Turned Judge Advertises for Patent Trolls t...
by arcticbull on Tuesday October 06, 2020 @03:28AM
(#24695460)
Just saying "we should trust judges" doesn't mean that a system of randomized selection for which judge isn't intrinsically valuable or meaningfully increase both confidence in and reliability of the system.
We should trust judges.
We should also create a system that strives to reduce the chance that individual judges could get to a point where they're less than trustworthy. Judges are people too, and respond to incentives. And yeah some individual judges suck, and are bad at their jobs. Like some doctors, and some lawyers, and some engineers.
A system that reduces their impact and influence, like randomization does, minimizes the harm of a bad apple, and also reduces their blast radius. They can't advertise that they'll adjudicate your case.
After all, isn't this why we have appeals courts? If you could trust your individual judge implicitly, why allow an appeal?
Trust, sure, but verify.
> Or what happens if I accuse the randomizer of being untrustworthy?
Open source the RNG. Let people see for themselves. Publish the stats that show it's a uniform random distribution.
We should trust judges.
We should also create a system that strives to reduce the chance that individual judges could get to a point where they're less than trustworthy. Judges are people too, and respond to incentives. And yeah some individual judges suck, and are bad at their jobs. Like some doctors, and some lawyers, and some engineers.
A system that reduces their impact and influence, like randomization does, minimizes the harm of a bad apple, and also reduces their blast radius. They can't advertise that they'll adjudicate your case.
After all, isn't this why we have appeals courts? If you could trust your individual judge implicitly, why allow an appeal?
Trust, sure, but verify.
> Or what happens if I accuse the randomizer of being untrustworthy?
Open source the RNG. Let people see for themselves. Publish the stats that show it's a uniform random distribution.