Leave it to the landlord to miss whom property appreciation comes from. It ain’t you! It’s the people living there that make your property more valuable over time. If your renters do well your property value rises.
I don’t know. I mean you might be coming from a place culturally that simply diminishes how you benefit from the system. It’s a narrow minded, ill conceived, jingoist, reductionist culture that attributes all personal good to multi-generational hard work and independence or whatever and belittles the losers for being stupid or lazy or having inadequate families or whatever. But a professional landlord must certainly understand the basic economics of why their renters doing well is also good for them. It boggles the mind to make an error like that, which is why I’m suspecting it would take years of conditioning to be skeptical of your customer’s success.
* Can I force my tenant to make up the difference if I sell into a down market?
* If I support policies that keep house prices steady, do I get any brownie points in this conversation? I'm something of a Georgist btw,
That appreciation ain't worth much to an owner forced to sell cheaply after losing their rental stream. You're talking about trading very real value right now for reasonable but ultimately speculative returns.
Could you explain this more fully? I would say that the value rises because there is more demand for the property, not because someone who makes $200,000 a year lives there. If your claim is true, then how does the market know which properties contain successful individuals so the property value increases accordingly?
1) If owning a rental property makes me responsible for my tenant's failures and misfortune beyond a rental contract:
- Why am I not also entitled to a cut of their successes beyond the rental contract?
- If they are making decisions that affect my financial prosperity, when will I get a say? Can I demand they go into IT rather than going for a communications degree?
- What do you think of the incentives that puts on me not to ever rent my property out to poor people?
2) People have to exist, they need ... medicine ...
That word "medicine" is much more flexible than the others (fed & shelter are binary things), it changes over time. What standard are we applying here? Does the landlord get to object if they give themselves a lifestyle disease, eg, smoker gets lung cancer or tenant refuses to wear a mask for political reasons and then gets COVID? Where is the line for rare conditions that cost a large fortune to treat, verging on untreatable?