Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai...
by pchristensen on Sunday October 04, 2020 @10:32AM
(#24679323)
It’s much more complicated than that. If you’re interested, Alon Levy of Pedestrian Observations compares transit construction costs across countries, for example why some countries like Spain and South Korea can build subways for 1/10 the cost per mile of USA construction projects. It basically comes down to “no one tried to make this cheaper”. Culture and history seem to be the primary drivers, more than labor costs, unions, corruption, environmental regulations, NIMBYs, etc.
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai...
by bnralt on Sunday October 04, 2020 @05:31PM
(#24682412)
Thanks, this is a great read[1]. The incuriosity he sees as the reason why nothing is done is something I've seen a lot of, and have been thinking more and more about. As he notes, it's not just lack of interest in making things better, but refusing to believe better is possible even when presented with examples of better systems.
[1] https://pedestrianobservations.com/2019/03/03/why-american-c...
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai...
by pnw_hazor on Sunday October 04, 2020 @01:45PM
(#24680800)
Many local US governments establish prevailing wage-laws that set minimum wages for construction jobs that private contractors have to abide by if they go work for the government.
https://secure.lni.wa.gov/wagelookup/ApprenticeWageLookup.as...
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai...
by TwoBit on Sunday October 04, 2020 @01:05PM
(#24680513)
> no one tried to make this cheaper
What do you mean by this?
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai...
by pchristensen on Sunday October 04, 2020 @04:38PM
(#24682102)
It was never an organizational goal to reduce the cost of delivering infrastructure. Picture an overweight, out of shape person. Literally anything you do can improve health - portion size, macro balance, calorie restriction, daily exercise, intensity of exercise, change of environment, removal of food temptations, variety of exercise, cardio, weights, sports, etc. You don’t have to be a dietician or personal trainer to help this person. But if they don’t want to lose weight, they’re not going to try any of these.
Much of American infrastructure provision is like that hypothetical person - the goal is never to to spend less. Political and organizational goals are to increase budget, increase headcount, deliver ribbon cutting ceremonies, avoid affecting neighborhoods with powerful constituents, hit service coverage goals, create construction and operations jobs, etc. There’s no one whose job evaluation and advancement is based on reducing costs.
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai...
by yardie on Sunday October 04, 2020 @08:09AM
(#24678396)
Same projects in Western Europe are coming in significantly lower. Labor is cited as the main cost but it’s easy to hide corruption in labor costs.
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai...
by bnt on Sunday October 04, 2020 @09:52AM
(#24679052)
But Western Europe (EU) has the benefit of temporarily importing cheap East European (Romania, Poland etc) under skilled workers to do the heavy lifting.
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai...
by burntoutfire on Sunday October 04, 2020 @11:28AM
(#24679718)
Aren't there like 10 million illegal immigrants in the US who serve similar function?
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai...
by xyzzyz on Sunday October 04, 2020 @04:19PM
(#24681977)
In NYC, the labor law requires paying "prevailing wage", which NYC decided is $100k+/year. See https://comptroller.nyc.gov/services/for-the-public/nyc-wage... No wonder that all public projects are so expensive.
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai...
by theptip on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:22PM
(#24680159)
Presumably not for public contracts.
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai...
by Xylakant on Sunday October 04, 2020 @02:53PM
(#24681370)
Western European Countries usually have a law in place that labor brought in for these contracts has to be paid the same wage as local labor.
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai...
by Spooky23 on Sunday October 04, 2020 @08:53AM
(#24678662)
This isn’t NYC. We outsourced to places like this before Mexico and China were options.
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai...
by rightbyte on Sunday October 04, 2020 @07:49AM
(#24678277)
That is not a problem if you got "high cost labor" taxpayers.
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai...
by DarthGhandi on Sunday October 04, 2020 @08:22AM
(#24678465)
We have "construction robots" already. It's called foreign labour and no one in the West would dare suggest bringing them in for one-off large infrastructure projects regardless of how many cost-benefit-analyses you can get the smartest economists on Earth to produce, nor the willingness of the laborers to do it.
We need construction robots.