Re:Steve Yegge v. Rich Hickey re: "Clojure just needs to sta...
by ScottBurson on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @07:33PM
(#2468845)
Funny you should mention Common Lisp, which has become the ultimate "no" language -- its spec has been cast in stone for a quarter century now. No threads, no module system (beyond packages), no new collection types, etc. etc. etc.
I'm not saying this is a good thing, but you seem to contradict yourself by liking CL at the same time you agree with Steve Yegge.
Re:Steve Yegge v. Rich Hickey re: "Clojure just needs to sta...
by gruseom on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @09:25PM
(#2469103)
Common Lisp, which has become the ultimate "no" language
By historical accident. I'm talking about language design. Yegge says much the same thing about CL in the OP, by the way.
Re:Steve Yegge v. Rich Hickey re: "Clojure just needs to sta...
by scott_s on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @01:47PM
(#2467586)
I think Python is both prescriptive and widely popular.
Re:Steve Yegge v. Rich Hickey re: "Clojure just needs to sta...
by pnathan on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @04:19PM
(#2468206)
I have found Python to break down as I scale it into a larger system spanning multiple directories and modules.
It's fine for bashing out 3-4 file programs. It's a decently high-entropy language.
It's a bloody lousy hacking language because of the prescriptiveness.
I'd rather use Common Lisp, and I do, for personal stuff.
Re:Steve Yegge v. Rich Hickey re: "Clojure just needs to sta...
by dpritchett on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @02:01PM
(#2467655)
It's also one of the more readable languages in existence and it's implicitly championed by an IT juggernaut.
Re:Steve Yegge v. Rich Hickey re: "Clojure just needs to sta...
by Kaizyn on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @03:09PM
(#2467941)
It was popular before Google started championing it.
Re:Steve Yegge v. Rich Hickey re: "Clojure just needs to sta...
by swannodette on Wednesday April 20, 2011 @02:29PM
(#2467764)
Not for production code it isn't.
Yegge isn't arguing for the abandonment of taste and rigour in a race to incorporate every kitchen appliance into the language. He's arguing that languages and communities that take a prescriptive (someone said "paternalistic") stance end up marginalizing themselves by their own rigidity, and that the antidote for this -- as well as the passageway toward wider adoption -- is to actively listen to and court new users. I couldn't agree more.
(Side note, this is why I like Common Lisp. Its loosey-goosey flexibility that always assumes the programmer knows best leads to an awesome fluidity that finds its around any obstacle. CL is unpopular, but not because of its pluralism. Qua language it has a deep respect for the user.)
There's another point here. Whether you're a fan of Steve Yegge or not (I didn't use to be, but after nodding with everything he said here I am now), he has a proven ability to mobilize a significant body of programmer opinion. To ignore what this guy says about the marketing of programming languages itself already displays a foolish disregard for the market.