News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Palantir goes public but founders will have control for life by trowaway888 on Friday October 02, 2020 @11:11AM (#24663441)
Genuinely curious, how is Palantir a threat to liberty?
Re:Palantir goes public but founders will have control for life by smt88 on Friday October 02, 2020 @11:25AM (#24663574)
They are a highly-secretive company that sell secret digital surveillance services to governments, including law enforcement.

As a private company, they're not subject to FOIA requests the same way govt orgs (including military, with obvious redactions) are.

Re:Palantir goes public but founders will have control for life by manfredo on Friday October 02, 2020 @12:16PM (#24664116)
I don't think it's correct to say that they sell surveillance services. When I think of "surveillance" I think it means data collection. Palantir doesn't build data collection tools, they build data visualization tools. The government already has the data, Palantir builds a tool to better browse that data. The tool Palantir replaces if often Microsoft Excel. Does it follow that Excel is a digital surveillance tool?
Re:Palantir goes public but founders will have control for life by NationalPark on Friday October 02, 2020 @12:32PM (#24664299)
You've made this distinction a couple times in these comments and I just don't buy it. If Palantir doesn't provide any value, why does the government keep hiring them to build "visualizations" of domestic surveillance tools? I think we can both oppose this kind of policy politically, and rightfully call out the companies and the individual engineers who do this kind of anti-privacy work.
Re:Palantir goes public but founders will have control for life by manfredo on Friday October 02, 2020 @12:39PM (#24664381)
The ability to better visualize this info, is the value. Governments are willing to pay for Palantir because doing things tracking down pill mills is easier if you can perform operations like filtering for people that bought the same drug twice in a day, and then plotting those purchases on map. It's a lot harder to do this kind of analysis with Excel.
Re:Palantir goes public but founders will have control for life by smt88 on Friday October 02, 2020 @01:07PM (#24664686)
So what if Palantir is selling facial recognition software?

That's technically the same: post-processing (video) data that the government has already collected.

Or what if they are doing predictive crime? Or tracking suspected criminals across marketing data sets?

Surveillance is dangerous at its core because it gives the govt power to target one or more people. If Palantir is doing that (and it is), then it has the same potential for harm as any other surveillance product.

[dead]
Re:Palantir goes public but founders will have control for life by edoceo on Friday October 02, 2020 @11:46AM (#24663807)
It is. But @trowaway888 is a 35 minute old throwaway sea-lion account - they're not interested in discussion
Re:Palantir goes public but founders will have control for life by kbenson on Friday October 02, 2020 @11:55AM (#24663906)
Whether they are interested or not, they aren't the only person that will see the reply. Sea-lioning seems to work best when people have left their reasoning out. For a site like this, sea-lioning at the base level is probably a public service. It's when it's used against people that have already explained themselves that it's problematic.
Re:Palantir goes public but founders will have control for life by polynomial on Friday October 02, 2020 @01:20PM (#24664805)
Interesting, I learned a new word today. Would the repeated questioning of Trump about White Supremacy fall under this trope?
Re:Palantir goes public but founders will have control for life by kbenson on Friday October 02, 2020 @07:04PM (#24667926)
Honestly, I heard it for the first time within the last week myself. While I'm sure it is a problem in some cases, so far I've seen more people complaining about sea-lioning than actual cases where it was both obvious it was being used as a tactic and negative.

As for Trump, maybe I could see it if he didn't stumble or fail to answer half the time, and come up with a controversial and ambiguous answer the rest of the time, and didn't spend of lot of effort communicating what seems like the opposite of his official answers on his own time? He's not the kind of person it's easy to say has a specific opinion or stance since he's contradicting himself constantly and revising earlier statements by saying they were jokes, but then later they were jokes but not really.... So who knows.