As someone completely unaffiliated with Hacktoberfest (only attendee over several years), my impression is that there really haven’t been much issues with it until this year.
I’m quite confident it was all done in good faith.
Unlike all those shit, SPAM PRs.
As far as I'm aware, there are already 4500+ repos which have had a low quality, single-line-change, "Improve Docs" PR opened in the past two days.
Just to pull out a few repos out for example purposes:
* 7 spam - https://github.com/seductivegeese/softi.es
* 8 spam - https://github.com/easydepot/websiteSwallower/pulls
* 8 spam - https://github.com/tokio-rs/website
* 13 spam - https://github.com/phpmyadmin/website
* 15+ spam - https://github.com/pyvec/elsa
* 15+ spam - https://github.com/justicedemocrats/candidate-website
* 15+ spam - https://github.com/Salamek/blacklist
* 20+ spam - https://github.com/openmaptiles/www.openmaptiles.org
* 25+ spam - https://github.com/blitz-js/blitzjs.com
* 60+ spam - https://github.com/EdmontonPy/edmontonpy
Heck, take look at the PRs and commit history of https://github.com/azmat21/UyghurWebsiteCrawler. It's been two days into October, and this repo has gotten 55 PRs. It hasn't ever gotten a single PR before this as far as I can tell.
I find it troublesome that a room full of people and no one raised a concern about how the whole thing would be misused, and wasted time of hundreds of maintainers who now have to clean up their repo. Did "the room" consider this, at all, and what if they did, what was the conclusion?
Edit: I added neom's original comment, still have it on my browser.