Every story and comment from the Hacker News API, in a layout borrowed from 2001.
A comment on YouTubers are upscaling the past to 4K, but historians want them to stop. Parent comment
The article unfortunately doesn't point out why this is a naive take.
If you upscale an image for display on a 4k display, you can:
1. Leave an aliasing artifact intact.
2. Remove an aliasing artifact.
Now, suppose you have two clients-- one making a documentary about the moon landing, and another making a documentary about moon landing conspiracies.
Pick your favorite "sincere and accurate" ML algorithm-- it cannot generate a single image that will be suitable for use by both clients.
Perhaps "straining and toiling" is hyperbole. But I don't see an alternative to careful, deliberate study of the primary sources of history.
Also-- keep in mind that was a didactic example. When you talk about colorizing films or cartoons, things get quite muddy.
There are no comments on this comment yet.
The article unfortunately doesn't point out why this is a naive take.
If you upscale an image for display on a 4k display, you can:
1. Leave an aliasing artifact intact.
2. Remove an aliasing artifact.
Now, suppose you have two clients-- one making a documentary about the moon landing, and another making a documentary about moon landing conspiracies.
Pick your favorite "sincere and accurate" ML algorithm-- it cannot generate a single image that will be suitable for use by both clients.
Perhaps "straining and toiling" is hyperbole. But I don't see an alternative to careful, deliberate study of the primary sources of history.
Also-- keep in mind that was a didactic example. When you talk about colorizing films or cartoons, things get quite muddy.