News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Grand Design (2010) by nendroid on Thursday October 01, 2020 @03:57PM (#24655530)
All mutations are accidental. Whether a macro feature on a biological lifeform is accidental feature or a feature driven through generations of natural selection can be judged through the complexity of the outcome. Complexity arises from random mutations being selected and building on each other.

A complex module in our brain that formulates moral judgements on certain behaviors is by probability more likely to be an outcome of generations of natural selection. Such a module arising by accident is roughly equivalent to the probability of a tornado self assembling a 747 airliner from random junk by accident.

Re:The Grand Design (2010) by AnimalMuppet on Thursday October 01, 2020 @07:01PM (#24657072)
You're pulling out the "tornado in a junkyard" argument to advocate for evolution? There are those who think that exact same argument applies to something like morals arising as the result of a series of accidental mutations.
Re:The Grand Design (2010) by nendroid on Thursday October 01, 2020 @09:30PM (#24657898)
I'm not arguing against it.

I'm saying morals are a macro feature arising from a series of accidental mutations as opposed to a macro feature arising as a side effect similar to your snoring example.

The complexity of the moral module is too complex to be a single accidental mutation... it must be naturally selected out of a multitude of mutations building on each other to produce such a feature. This is very unlike snoring which is caused by mechanisms that are far more simplistic.