News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ontario doctors sign letter to Premier advising against s... by sdesol on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @10:48PM (#24646761)
> Anyone can always choose to self-isolate based on their own personal risk factors and risk tolerance

you forgot to include "provided they can afford to".

Re:Ontario doctors sign letter to Premier advising against s... by mb7733 on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @10:51PM (#24646788)
True, but re-introducing lockdown doesn't help anyone afford anything. More like the opposite.
Re:Ontario doctors sign letter to Premier advising against s... by sdesol on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @11:06PM (#24646885)
I think "doesn't help anyone" is a bit of a stretch, since many tech workers actually did quite well during the lockdown, since they were forced to spend less due to a lack of options.

I'm in Ontario so what is being discussed does have an affect on me and I really don't know if a lockdown is the answer. What I do know is our Premier (Doug Ford) is a fuck up. We should be much more prepared by now and this lock-down talk is him panicking because we have no way better way to manage outbreaks.

Re:Ontario doctors sign letter to Premier advising against s... by GhostVII on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @11:03PM (#24646864)
If they can't afford to self-isolate on their own, they also can't afford to self-isolate under government orders. Locking everyone else down doesn't help those who are at risk afford isolation, it actually makes it much more difficult because the government has less money to work with to support those who are at risk.
Re:Ontario doctors sign letter to Premier advising against s... by nrmitchi on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @11:16PM (#24646949)
What you (Edit: not _you_ in particular, but what a country does by making self-isolation opt-in) are doing here is shifting the blame of who is responsible.

If the government says that you must stay home for public health, then it is reasonable to expect that the government assists in covering costs associated with that.

As soon as the government says "You can go to work if you feel it best, the choice is up to you" a non-trivial amount of people are going to be forced to go back to work, whether they feel like they should or not. Because "you're allowed to, staying home was your choice", these people will not be compensated for making the public-safety choice.

I don't know about you, but I wouldn't want to be in a situation where the person who is making my lunch (or stocking grocery shelves, etc) should have stayed home, knows they should have stayed home, but couldn't afford to stay home because "it's not mandatory".

Re:Ontario doctors sign letter to Premier advising against s... by GhostVII on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @11:23PM (#24646993)
Then the government should compensate those who are staying at home because they are at risk. If the choice is between locking everyone down and compensating everyone, and just compensating those who are at risk the second option is obviously cheaper.

And regardless, I think the vast majority of those who are at risk were not working before the pandemic, so do not really need to be compensated. More than 60% of people who have died so far in Ontario are in long term care facilities. Over 85% of people who have died in Ontario are in their 70's or older (so likely retired). So the number of at-risk people we are talking about here is actually pretty small.

Re:Ontario doctors sign letter to Premier advising against s... by ineedasername on Thursday October 01, 2020 @01:10AM (#24647541)
Then the government should compensate those who are staying at home because they are at risk.

Maybe, but it's wishful thinking, never going to happen. Think of the outcry against the $600 unemployment supplement where some people received more than they were making previously, not to mention arguments that it incentivized staying unemployed.

Re:Ontario doctors sign letter to Premier advising against s... by jtbayly on Thursday October 01, 2020 @12:14AM (#24647284)
In which case, locking just them down would accomplish nothing, since they are already “locked down.”
Re:Ontario doctors sign letter to Premier advising against s... by tinus_hn on Thursday October 01, 2020 @05:31PM (#24656332)
Do you think governments have some kind of magical money well? Every cent they spend has to be paid by someone and if no one is earning how are they going to pay taxes?

Besides obviously if everyone is in lockdown, how are you going to buy food in a closed store with empty shelves? Do you think the government can just write a law and bread appears? People actually have to do a lot of work to make it.

Re:Ontario doctors sign letter to Premier advising against s... by sdesol on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @11:18PM (#24646964)
> If they can't afford to self-isolate on their own, they also can't afford to self-isolate under government orders.

Well this is true now, now that CERB is over. But before, those that were eligible, received 2000 a month from the government.

> government has less money to work with to support those who are at risk

There are now talks about a serious wealth tax on the rich to help fund future covid efforts that will allow those that can't afford to self isolate, to be able to.

Re:Ontario doctors sign letter to Premier advising against s... by zaroth on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @11:04PM (#24646869)
You’re absolutely right. Unemployment benefits should absolutely be available to anyone who can’t do their job as a consequence of choosing to shelter-in-place.

Countries can much better afford to offer unemployment benefits to the “at-risk sheltering” population than they can to offer the same benefits across their entire working population. Most working age people are not at high risk.

Provided you’re not paying people more to not work than they would earn working, you can let the market decide.

Re:Ontario doctors sign letter to Premier advising against s... by tinus_hn on Thursday October 01, 2020 @05:24PM (#24656281)
As if the tooth fairy is going to pay if there’s a general lockdown. Either the government forces employers to keep paying their workers so they all get fired or the businesses go under, or they allow them to curtail wages. The government can’t afford to pick up the tab.