News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is it time to kill the calculus curriculum? by foxyv on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @04:41PM (#24643566)
Calculus is absolutely essential for most science. However I think Calculus in High School is a bit ridiculous. If a student has reached that point they should be transitioning to a middle college program where they can spend more time on the subject without burning out dealing with the High School hoop jumping.
Re:Is it time to kill the calculus curriculum? by dragonwriter on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @04:44PM (#24643603)
> However I think Calculus in High School is a bit ridiculous. If a student has reached that point they should be transitioning to a middle college program where they can spend more time on the subject without burning out dealing with the High School hoop jumping.

It's possible for a student to be advanced in math but not equally advanced in other fields; it's also possible for a student to be academically but not emotionally advanced; both of these may make it better for a student who is academically prepared for calculus to pursue it in high school rather than a post-secondary environment.

Re:Is it time to kill the calculus curriculum? by foxyv on Friday October 02, 2020 @12:10PM (#24664061)
High School is a time waster. It's designed to waste as much time as possible so that parents don't have to pay for child care. At the same time it's putting kids into extreme stress situations. Sitting in a classroom for hour long stretches, overcrowding, bullying, authoritarian discipline and arbitrary rules. 5 hours of lectures per day, 5 days a week with a vaguely humiliating hour of physical education which involves stripping in front of other people.

If the kid is ready for college, then do it!

Re:Is it time to kill the calculus curriculum? by pessimizer on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @05:35PM (#24644211)
College/University is easier than high school, and high school is no emotional safety bubble. High school is probably the most emotionally intense and punishing period of one's life in my opinion. School gets increasingly worse and worse from the first year until the last year of HS, and college is a relief.
Re:Is it time to kill the calculus curriculum? by jhbadger on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @05:05PM (#24643839)
"Most science" meaning physics. Calculus is of little use to either chemistry or biology. I took three semesters of it, and used very little of since despite majoring in biochemistry and getting a doctorate in microbiology. On the other hand, I wish I had studied more statistics. That's what is actually useful.
Re:Is it time to kill the calculus curriculum? by foxyv on Friday October 02, 2020 @11:50AM (#24663856)
Chemistry has a great deal to do with calculus. Reaction rates, statistical mechanics, and physical chemistry are a few off the top of my head. That's where all those equations we memorize come from. Sure we could just learn the equations, but then what happens when we run into something that doesn't fit the neat assumptions that were made for that particular equation?

Statistics uses calculus heavily as well. It's hard to determine the probability of something lying in a range of a standard distribution without integrals.

On the other hand, 90% of the people going through college that take calculus are there to get education to do a job that requires little to no calculus. The hard part is predicting which 10% we should educate. Teaching calculus leaves the option open for that 10% to do the jobs that need it.

Re:Is it time to kill the calculus curriculum? by dwheeler on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @05:19PM (#24643996)
Calculus is the underpinning of statistics and probability. So you don't get rid of calculus that way :-).

I think more discrete math - at least first-order predicate calculus - should be added to high school math. But that would not take a lot of extra time, you could sandwich that into other things.

Re:Is it time to kill the calculus curriculum? by kzrdude on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @05:09PM (#24643878)
Isn't calculus a prerequisite for statistics? Areas and density intuitions from calculus are very helpful.
Re:Is it time to kill the calculus curriculum? by jhbadger on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @06:04PM (#24644554)
In curricula yes, you have to take calculus courses first. And yes, maybe in some esoteric proofs you need it. But in real, useful statistics, that is actually analyzing data to see if it is statistically significant, calculus plays no role at all.
Re:Is it time to kill the calculus curriculum? by ACow_Adonis on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @05:24PM (#24644073)
the intuitions from calculus are helpful for both statistics and economics and bits of other sciences: derivatives, higher order derivatives, min/max, discontinuities, integrals, etc.

however, in my last 10 - 20 years I've never actually calculated an analytical derivative. I think there might be some economists somewhere who are doing so, but in my experience that's generally because they don't understand enough about computers or modelling, and they're just roting 30 year old techniques.

Re:Is it time to kill the calculus curriculum? by dbcooper on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @05:43PM (#24644304)
Nonsense. Physical chemistry and thermodynamics are underpinned by calculus. Try studying engineering without calculus ...
Re:Is it time to kill the calculus curriculum? by jhbadger on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @06:01PM (#24644529)
Physical chemistry is a minor subfield of chemistry, one in which I have never had to cause to use, even though my field deals with the chemical byproducts of microbes.
Re:Is it time to kill the calculus curriculum? by dbcooper on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @05:42PM (#24644289)
Please don't keep pushing fundamental education to colleges to fix. It just makes everyone worse, and fundamentally changes the role of universities - they are not there for remedial learning!
Re:Is it time to kill the calculus curriculum? by foxyv on Friday October 02, 2020 @12:01PM (#24663966)
Calculus is not remedial education. It is typically taught in the first 4 semesters of college. (Differential, Integral, Multivariable, DiffEq)

English composition, World History, US History, all are part of a BS program. Why make a kid sit through 4 years of remedial junk in High School when he is already at a college level?

But you are right, remedial stuff like grammar, writing, and Algebra should be taught at a Middle/High School. Kids shouldn't graduate until they are done with that. But keeping someone 4 years at a High School just to run out the clock on their DOE funding when they hit 18 is nuts when they are at a college level.